To me, it is. Dart fixed everything which was wrong with JavaScript. There is proper lexical scoping, a lexically scoped `this`, no type coercion, build-in classes/inheritance, built-in dependency handling, built-in annotations/doc-comments, and good tooling is also possible.
It really does scale and it's very nice to work with. Plus, there are a bunch of nice features like lambdas, mixins, and named arguments.
> Javascript as web bytecode just doesn't sound right to me.
Yea, it's kinda icky, but there doesn't really seem to be a way around it. Fortunately, dart2js' output is reasonable in terms of size and performance. Unfortunately, it doesn't work in IE8.
There is a package for making interacting with JSON more seamless and JavaScript-like:
http://pub.dartlang.org/packages/json_object
> Google being the main sponsor just makes me slightly wary of it
In that regard, I clearly prefer Google over Oracle or Microsoft. I was also happy with Sun back in the days.
That said Dart isn't that JS2. Perhaps that languages will never exist at all. I assume that what web might need is a VM that can run various languages on. And Javascript as web bytecode just doesn't sound right to me.