News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by jlgreco on Thursday May 23, 2013 @05:27AM (#5755937)
I don't think I could disagree with the author more, and I am coming from the perspective of someone who also bought a pixel. (Actually we agree there, it is the best put together machine I've ever used... more on that later.)

I'm not running ChromeOS on my pixel right now. I tried it for a weekend, it wasn't my cup of tea, and I slapped Debian onto it instead. No big surprise there, I have different needs from most computer users. I want a web browser, a tiling window manager, and a metric fuckton of urxvt's on my screen at once... it doesn't surprise or concern me that I didn't like ChromeOS. I also don't like OSX and Windows 7/8; clearly I have minority interests.

Who is the target user of these systems then? Well, I may not like OSX or Windows, but I certainly understand at least a segment of their market. If my mother asks me for an opinion on what computer to get, I'm going to tell her to get a mac, or to stick with the windows Thinkpads she's traditionally gotten. Either of those are great for her, great for browsing the web, watching videos, and viewing pictures from her camera. Now, as I understand the marketing materials, this should make ChromeOS (probably not the pixel, considering the cost, but ChromeOS) a perfect choice for her. I wouldn't even consider recommending ChromeOS to her though, the reality of ChromeOS does not seem to fit the marketing materials or the author of this article's described reality.

I tried browsing pictures from my phone on it. My android phone. Fucking awful experience. All of the shine but none of the grace of OSX. Wasted screen-space everywhere, piss-poor file navigation, the works. Alright then, how about watching some videos? Plug in my portable harddrive only to discover that the video player on the thing has all the codec/container support of a bargain-brand smart-tv from 2007. My stock android phone does video a thousand times better than this shit. Fine, maybe I was expecting too much of the default video player. I don't expect my preferred mplayer to be available, but my brothers got my mother hooked on VLC a few years ago. Can I try that? Hahahaha no, what was I thinking? Alright, alright, what about webbrowsing? Well I guess it works exactly as you would expect. You open chrome and browse the web... nothing to complain about, nothing to get excited about. So score one for ChromeOS I guess?

The Pixel's hardware though.. my god it is fantastic. Well, aside from the absurdly tiny harddrive which would cripple any offline user with usage patterns terribly dissimilar from mine (for example: my mother). And aside from the uninspired RAM and processor offering... Those are not big complaints though, those failings don't represent significant technical challenges. They are things that could easily be fixed in the next revision. If those things are resolved the next generation of Pixel could be a serious contender, as a piece of hardware, to any of Apple's offerings. They just don't have the software to do it though. If this ChromeOS crap does end up taking off in a few years it will be despite the current state of affairs, much like Android's current popularity is despite the abysmal quality of earlier versions. The market for desktop OS's is entirely different from the 2007-era smartphone market though; ChromeOS isn't "that thing you use if your executives shit their pants when the iPhone was unveiled."

Who would I recommend a pixel to? Nobody... nobody except for a very small list of users that I know have usage patterns very similar to my own (and to them I could not recommend the computer strongly enough). This could easily be fixed though. Their hardware could have a future for itself.

Who would I recommend ChromeOS to, with any imaginable hardware? I honestly have no idea, and I don't see that changing anytime soon.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by wslh on Thursday May 23, 2013 @08:10AM (#5756355)
I agree that ChromeOS as a base operating system is difficult to imagine but I think that the new rich GUI is moving towards HTML (beyond its use for browsing). Flash, Silverlight, and WPF will be replaceable very soon. Metro has a similar goal but less "standard".

I also prefer to have the opportunity to use the browser engine as a rich GUI but develop in any programming language (like Python or C#). It seems like this is not the Google vision because there is not an official Google's WebKit COM bindings for Windows while Apple has a good Javascript/Objective-C integration.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by jlgreco on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:42PM (#5757807)
Using HTML to create an entire user interface seems entirely reasonable to me, and a hell of a lot more pleasant to work with as a developer than the traditional way of doing things.
Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by wslh on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:46PM (#5758217)
Yes, one area where Microsoft is ahead of Google is in designing interfaces within the IDE. Probably this trend is changing since Android Studio but I am waiting for the HTML/CSS/JS Studio (not Aptana/Eclipse).
Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by columbo on Thursday May 23, 2013 @10:30AM (#5756973)
This is really off topic, but could you speak to the battery life of the pixel running Debian? What you're describing is exactly what I'd like to do.
Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by jlgreco on Thursday May 23, 2013 @11:59AM (#5757571)
Seems to run between 4 and 5 hours. Not great, but it seems to be about in line with what people get with ChromeOS.

Also I run >3.9.0 kernels from git for clickpad/touchscreen support. Other than that everything is from Wheezy.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Thursday May 23, 2013 @08:53AM (#5756528)
You're confusing me, honestly. If you have a Windows box, and want to view photos, would you settle for Paint? No, you'd be nuts to.

So when you want to browse pictures from your phone on your Chromebox, upload them to flickr, and the experience is awesome.

When you want to watch some videos on your Chromebox, you watch Netflix Instant Watch, or YouTube, or Google Play Movies, and the experience is awesome.

It's like you're comparing Vanilla Windows to Vanilla Chrome. Why are you tying one arm behind your back, like that? Install some programs on that Windows box, and use the best of the web on your Chromebox.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by sbuk on Thursday May 23, 2013 @10:56AM (#5757154)
But you wouldn't use Paint. The Windows Photo View and Explorer actually do a more than adequate job. Windows Media Player too does a reasonable job of playing video. Netflix, YouTube and Google Play Movies don't solve the problem of plying my videos. The Mac, modern desktop Linux distos and Windows support the functionality that the OP and you crave out of the box - as do most tables, including the iPad. I just don't see where Chrome OS fits in.
Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Thursday May 23, 2013 @11:17AM (#5757276)
Yes, YouTube does solve the problem of playing your videos. And sharing them with your friends. And archiving them, in case of disaster. If you're willing to use YouTube, of course. If not, you can use Smugmug or Flickr or Vimeo or...

ChromeOS is inherently an operating system that uses the internet to solve users' problems.

Expecting ChromeOS to have BUILT-IN ways to do what you want to, is kind of silly, in my mind. I validate that you may reject the design idea, but you're forcing it into solving problems in a way it was inherently and intentionally NOT designed to solve them.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by jlgreco on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:02PM (#5757589)
Viewing photographs and videos is something that ChromeOS does. It is not asking too much of it to do it well.

They gave it the ability to play videos and pictures offline because even they know it is absurd to expect the user to upload all their videos and pictures.. at least prior to viewing them. They just did a half-assed job of it.

I tried looking for programs on ChromeOS to install to fix these things, the offerings are either universally abysmal or for once Google has completely failed at search because I failed to find anything that wasn't abysmal.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:18PM (#5757668)
In the analogy, Chrome is Linux.

If you want a full-fledged system, you use GNU/Linux, or probably a distro like Ubuntu.

If you want a full-fledged system from Chrome, you use the Internet.

You can text edit with sed, but that's not how anyone uses Linux, in real life, right?

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by jlgreco on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:23PM (#5757698)
One might argue that a Linux distro without vi, ex/ed, or at least nano/pico, but rather just sed is ludicrous because no user operates like that.

If they included sed and intended it to be your text editor, as ChromeOS has included half-assed local picture and video playing (is this not what those things are for? Am I supposed to be using these things for stream manipulation, not picture/video viewing? Because if that is the case, their UI has failed to convey that.), then I would without hesitation assert that their distro was poorly considered.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by ised on Friday May 24, 2013 @12:39AM (#5761300)
I must inform you that there is a user who uses sed over all other text editors: me. I do use vi but I could easily survive without it; I have countless custom utilities that rely on sed. Surviving without sed would be difficult. Imagine a system that has pipes but where you cannot "write to disk"; where you do not have a TMPDIR for ed to use. With sed, this poses no problem.
Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Friday May 24, 2013 @08:24AM (#5762280)
Just out of curiosity - your resume was written in sed?
Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by ised on Friday May 24, 2013 @04:21PM (#5765008)
Actually, I used fmt. Then groff and ghostscript.

The job of fmt could be done with sed, of course. As many of HN'ers know, sed can perform the functions of many other UNIX utils. If used as an "all-purpose" program, perhaps it raises the possibility of the typical mantras about "the right tool for the job". But consider this: editing/transforming text (e.g. output from other programs) as a "job" is somewhat all-encompassing under UNIX. Everything can be a "file" and every file can be represented as "text" (e.g. ASCII, hex). What varies is the context in which you do this job of editing/transforming. It might be preprocessing source code (text) for gcc or maybe it's preprocessing a resume (text) for groff.

"When all you know is a sed, everything is a text." - Unknown

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:26PM (#5757712)
"Their distro" is the Internet.

A Chromebook without the Internet is ludicrous, because no user operates like that.

They might have been better off to not have the local picture and video player. They're the embarrassing "Notepad," if I want to make the analogy to Windows, again.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by jlgreco on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:34PM (#5757752)
"A Chromebook without the Internet is ludicrous, because no user operates like that."

I don't believe that anybody doesn't. Even android phones have better offline capabilities (Way better, and generally with less offline storage to boot) and people expect their phones to always be online.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Thursday May 23, 2013 @03:06PM (#5758778)
"I don't believe that anybody doesn't."

Here are the devices I own that are always online, when they're on:

TiVo, Logitech Revue, Wii, Chromebook, Android 1, Android 2, iPhone, Desktop 1, Desktop 2, Laptop 1, Laptop 2, Laptop 3, Laptop 4, and Kindle Fire. (I might be missing a couple.)

I expect my Chromebook to ALWAYS be online. Not least of which, because my Chromebook has 3G, just like my first Android phone did.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by sbuk on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:03PM (#5757595)
"Expecting ChromeOS to have BUILT-IN ways to do what you want to, is kind of silly, in my mind." Why?
Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:15PM (#5757656)
My VCR doesn't have any BUILT-IN movies.

I really, honestly don't mean to be crass, but the analogy is apt to me.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by jlgreco on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:31PM (#5757738)
Besides mudding the issue by confusing data with function, the Chromebook does have these features, and there is nothing about it that even indicates these features are deliberately second class citizens.

In this analogy your VCR has the ability to write an input source to a cassette, all you've got to do is hit the record button on the front of it but is incapable of writing to the first or last 10 minutes of the tape. VCR company considers cassette consumption to be the primary VCR use-case and is the use-case they are concerned with. Is it reasonable to complain about the substandard record functionality that they shipped? Is it reasonable to question the market viability of a VCR so needlessly crippled?

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:45PM (#5757836)
Is there anything in Notepad to indicate it's a deliberately second-class citizen?

My Roku doesn't have any built-in movies, my DVD player doesn't have any built-in movies...

It's not "needlessly crippled," it's brand new. Windows 3.0 would be seen as needlessly crippled if it were released today.

Look, if you don't like it, that's fine. But you can't convince me that it's not a viable product for many people, in many use cases. It might not be right for you, and I'm not saying you're wrong about that.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by jlgreco on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:51PM (#5757874)
Notepad doesn't need to indicate that it is second-class because standard end users don't give shits about text editing. Standard end users use word processors. Text editing is itself a second class activity; playing your videos and browsing your pictures is not.

> My Roku doesn't have any built-in movies, my DVD player doesn't have any built-in movies...

Yeah, I'm starting to think you are deliberately being weird. My complaint is not that my movies were not pre-installed on the thing.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Thursday May 23, 2013 @01:55PM (#5758299)
DVD players can play movies, if you plug one in.

Chrome can play movies, if you connect to a site that has them.

Standard end users don't give shits about built-in apps in Chrome. Standard end users use web applications like Google Docs, Flickr, Facebook, Smugmug, and on and on...

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by jlgreco on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:32PM (#5758562)
ChromeOS can play movies... sometimes.

Here is a fun use-case for you: A mother sits down in front of her laptop with a swanky 10GB/mo dataplan from Verizon. To her right is a SD card, on which are several videos of her children at their latest soccer game. She plugs the SD card into her computer, the SD card reader slot being one of only 5 ports that it has.

Can she watch her videos, without blowing through her dataplan?

With ChromeOS all bets are off. ChromeOS professes to support such a use case, as does her Android phone. Unlike ChromeOS, she can be confident that her Android phone will not let her down.

This isn't a reason why I don't use ChromeOS. My reasons for not using ChromeOS are weirder, and I do not fault ChromeOS for not meeting my needs. Rather, these are reasons why I could never recommend ChromeOS to friends and family, people I otherwise recommend software that I do not like to.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Thursday May 23, 2013 @02:57PM (#5758710)
Yes, you have valid complaints, for why you wouldn't recommend today. I think those complaints are going to go away, over time.

The world of 10GB/mo dataplans is as dead as the world of 14.4 Kbps modems, it just doesn't know it yet. Google Fiber is going to push the other ISPs kicking and screaming into the modern world.

When I record videos on my Android Phone, they're automatically uploaded to the cloud for me. I can view them instantly. There are Android Cameras / Videocameras coming to the market that do the same trick.

Also, I'll point out to you that people in Moore, OK are looking through rubble for family photo albums. If they'd been in the cloud, instead...

Also, Notepad professes to be a word processor. It sucks at it, and ChromeOS's native video-watching app sucks at it.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by WayneDB on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:44PM (#5757828)
YouTube or any other Internet Only service does not solve the problem of playing my videos very well.

Why would I want to upload gigabytes of video instead of downloading a small program to play them locally? If I care about archiving things - why would I want to archive just my video files?

I don't think anyone expects ChromeOS to have many built-in ways of doing things - but I also don't expect ChromeOS to be very widely used because it's not solving users' problems very well at all. Unless of course...they add native apps ;) Then it could be something.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by jlgreco on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:48PM (#5757852)
Yeah, at the very least I would expect ChromeOS to be good at playing videos out of that massive 1TB Google Drive offering that the pixel gets you. I mean, what else are you going to burn up 1TB on, if not video?
Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Thursday May 23, 2013 @03:14PM (#5758837)
> Why would I want to upload gigabytes of video

To archive them. To share them.

> If I care about archiving things - why would I want to archive just my video files?

You wouldn't. You'd want to archive anything. I genuinely don't understand the point you were trying to make here.

> it's not solving users' problems very well at all

I disagree. It solves my problems better than most other devices. "Playing my videos," it does extremely well. Step one, I shoot them on my Android, so they're instantly uploaded. If I have a video that's not on Android, I upload it to YouTube to archive and share it.

Many people in Moore, OK are shifting through rubble, looking for family photos. I think backing photos and videos up online makes a ton of sense...

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by WayneDB on Thursday May 23, 2013 @08:20PM (#5760450)
I don't want or need to publish many of my videos or photos online. They are private; I'm a fairly private person.

Also - where am I supposed to put the terabytes of legally obtained digital media that I own? Can you upload every movie you own to YouTube? Furthermore, my NAS serves things quicker than any online service.

I also like a local player in case there's no Internet connection or if it's slow. I go camping in the mountains and my mobile provider has spotty coverage in remote regions.

So no, it doesn't solve the problem real well. I'll keep using my NAS and online backup service and general/full operating systems such as Windows, OS X, Debian and CentOS.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Thursday May 23, 2013 @09:05PM (#5760630)
> They are private; I'm a fairly private person.

You don't need to publish them. I have YouTube videos uploaded which can only be seen by me - with my two-factor authentication. I bet they're more secure than most backups that most HN'ers use.

> So no, it doesn't solve the problem real well.

I'd wager most users don't have terabytes of data, or need to watch movies when they go camping in the mountains.

Bummer it doesn't work for you, but I still think there a lot of people it would work for.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by WayneDB on Friday May 24, 2013 @04:40PM (#5765086)
> I have YouTube videos uploaded which can only be seen by me - with my two-factor authentication.

How can you be so sure? I think a Google employee or a three letter agency could probably look at them if they wanted to. What if Anonymous gets hold of them and wrongly identifies you as a bomber?

Also, I'd wager that most users don't need to have all of their videos, photos or other media available to them wherever they go or on whatever device they're using.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by skinnymuch on Thursday May 23, 2013 @10:59AM (#5757172)
You wouldn't use Paint to view pictures on vanilla Windows. You'd use apps far better suited (and already set as default).

I think you still have a point in your comment though.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Thursday May 23, 2013 @11:20AM (#5757299)
In Windows 3.1 days, I absolutely would have used Paint, if I were lucky enough to have it open my file type.

If you unplug both devices from the internet, there's absolutely no question at all which is superior - Windows, hands down, no argument from me.

But if you let a Chromebook get on the internet, and you're comfortable using the best tools on the internet to solve your problems... there's a lot going for a Chromebook.

Someone who says, "Well, sure, but what if you don't have internet???" Yes, that's totally true and valid. But I think it's almost equally valid to ask how well a Windows box does without power. In a lot of ways, a college ruled notebook and a No. 2 pencil has them both beat.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by greenyoda on Thursday May 23, 2013 @04:41PM (#5759406)
There are places where people want to use their computers where there's no internet, or very slow internet, or a fee for using the internet. For example, on airplanes.
Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by VikingCoder on Thursday May 23, 2013 @05:12PM (#5759567)
Yeah, and there are places where people want to use their computers where there's no power. For example, on airplanes.

More airplanes are getting internet, and power.

Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by yRetsyM on Thursday May 23, 2013 @05:57AM (#5756001)
What browser do you use?
Re:How Google plans to rule the computing world through Chrome by jlgreco on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:06PM (#5757607)
Elinks and chromium.