Re:Hacktivism gone wrong? Nearly 16,000 whistleblowers have ...
by pessimizer on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @11:10PM
(#5755117)
Seriously: are you a whistleblower if you report your neighbor to the cops for burning leaves?
My conception of a whistleblower is someone who reports the behavior of closed institutions to the public. Other institutions might then take actions on behalf of the public, but isn't what makes the whistleblower a whistleblower. If you work as an accountant for a major company that is avoiding paying taxes through obscure and morally questionable, yet legal loopholes, you're still a whistleblower. If you report your neighbor for burning leaves in his yard, you've got to be a narc.
Describing people who make anonymous reports to police as whistleblowers seems at least editorial, and at most simply deceptive.
edit: a better counter-example might be a defector from the Mafia who reports their illegal activities to the police. Is he/she a whistleblower, or a narc?
My conception of a whistleblower is someone who reports the behavior of closed institutions to the public. Other institutions might then take actions on behalf of the public, but isn't what makes the whistleblower a whistleblower. If you work as an accountant for a major company that is avoiding paying taxes through obscure and morally questionable, yet legal loopholes, you're still a whistleblower. If you report your neighbor for burning leaves in his yard, you've got to be a narc.
Describing people who make anonymous reports to police as whistleblowers seems at least editorial, and at most simply deceptive.
edit: a better counter-example might be a defector from the Mafia who reports their illegal activities to the police. Is he/she a whistleblower, or a narc?