News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Government Wants A Backdoor Into Your Online Communic... by btilly on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @09:39PM (#5754854)
To be clear, I think that vendors make their services "backdoorable" because they want to extract revenue from them and attract consumers.

I disagree. Most are "backdoorable" because it is easier to build a service that way.

For instance consider gmail. The hard requirement is that a person armed with a user name and password can login from a browser and get access to that email. The common requirement is that a person armed with the right cookie can get that email. Now in theory you could encrypt all of the emails on the server, but now your operations costs went through the roof. However if you store them in plain text then you can use smart indexing, and your operations costs are much more manageable.

However once you've decided to have plain text files on your server, EVEN IF you aren't doing anything with them other than storing/sending them to the user, you're now able to backdoor those files, and hence can be compared to by a court.

There have been many email systems out there. Open source (qmail, sendmail, etc), proprietary (Exchange, Dovecot, etc), hosted in the cloud (Hotmail, Gmail, etc), hosted at your company (Exim, Oracle Communications Messaging Server, etc), built on top of platforms not meant to do email (Lotus Notes being a prime example) and so on.

Every single one of the ones I named and many, many, more stored data in plain text and legal discovery could be compelled on them. Simply because that was the easiest way to build them. There are exceptions, but they are exceptions because they were meant to be. Hushmail comes to mind. However even there, even when it was designed to store data in encrypted format, if the government can find a way to force you to extract data, they will push you to do so. (See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hushmail for a description of the way in which the government got Hushmail to capture plain text, even though the data was stored in plain text.)

The moral? Often the government has access not because evil profit-mongering corporations did wrong, but simply because obvious technical decisions leave them able to do so. And this can be true even when those corporations made a good faith effort to make that impossible.

Re:The Government Wants A Backdoor Into Your Online Communic... by jlgreco on Wednesday May 22, 2013 @09:55PM (#5754908)
> Most are "backdoorable" because it is easier to build a service that way.

Okay sure, I can go with that. My point is that the reason is not "because the government makes them do it that way." I agree with all of what you are saying.

Tying into the original conversation, my beef with skype isn't so much that they were backdoorable but that they were backdoorable when they have been claiming for years that they are not.

Re:The Government Wants A Backdoor Into Your Online Communic... by declan on Thursday May 23, 2013 @12:03AM (#5755290)
This is well said. The thing is, though, that it was the non-Java version of Hushmail that was exploited by the Feds. The fact that it could be exploited shouldn't cast the end-to-end secure version in a negative light.

So who at Google is going to code an encrypted Gmail in their 20% time? Paid, of course, because the server won't know what ads to show. (You could put that intelligence in the client, but it seems a privacy-sensitive clientele wouldn't like even that info to leak.)

Re:The Government Wants A Backdoor Into Your Online Communic... by kamjam on Thursday May 23, 2013 @10:26AM (#5756953)
I'm sure Google already has an encrypted version of their Gmail service, but why would they shoot themselves in the foot and loose all that Ad revenue?

You could put that intelligence in the client, but there is only so much analysis you do do using JavaScript, I'm sure the computing power they have available on their servers is phenomenal, and add to that a huge databank of information they have available to be able to better match those ads to you. And you've already mentioned the privacy issue...

Re:The Government Wants A Backdoor Into Your Online Communic... by declan on Saturday May 25, 2013 @01:05AM (#5766415)
Google would choose to lose "all that ad revenue" if they could replace it with sufficient, and probably more lucrative, non-ad revenue through paying customers.