News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Japan Starts to Recharge After Two Lost Economic Decades by rayiner on Monday May 20, 2013 @12:07AM (#5735811)
People who espouse bitcoin: see Japan for a textbook example of why deflation is a bad thing. See: http://www.telegraph.co.uk/comment/personal-view/3563614/Wha....
Re:Japan Starts to Recharge After Two Lost Economic Decades by bdcs on Monday May 20, 2013 @12:35AM (#5735910)
Here[1] Nobel-laureate Milton Friedman, argues that the majority of money, specifically the stuff industry and consumers touch, should be constant-supply -- that is to say, identical to bitcoin's model.

"My favorite proposal really is a little bit more sophisticated—or less sophisticated if you want to look at it that way—than a straight increase in the quantity of money. I would—if I had my choice—freeze the amount of [currency plus bank reserves]. Not increase it."

I'd be interested in hearing your, and other's, thoughts on the topic.

[1]http://www.econlib.org/library/Columns/y2006/Friedmantranscr...

Re:Japan Starts to Recharge After Two Lost Economic Decades by rayiner on Monday May 20, 2013 @12:45AM (#5735936)
You're taking the quote out of context. "High powered money" is not what consumers touch, and it is not the majority of money. In the very next paragraph he says: "Now, you would think that that's a bad idea because there would be no provision for expansion; however, high-powered money [currency plus bank reserves] is a small fraction of total money and the ratio of total money to high-powered money has been going up over time."

For the definition of "high powered money", see: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monetary_base ("in economics, the monetary base (also base money, money base, high-powered money, reserve money, or, in the UK, narrow money) is defined as the sum of currency circulating in the public and commercial banks' reserves with the central bank. The monetary base must not be confused with the money supply which consists of currency circulating in the public and non-bank deposits with commercial banks. Normally, the money supply excceds the monetary base by far; the ratio of the two is referred to as the money multiplier. If one excludes currency from the definitions, the monetary base is not a subset of the money supply - rather, the two are disjoint sets. On the commercial banks' balance sheets, the former belongs to the assets whereas the latter belongs to the liabilities.")

With Bitcoin, the total money supply is fixed (which Friedman acknowledges as a "bad idea" in your quote), not just the monetary base, because there is no fractional reserve banking in Bitcoins (or at least I'm not clear how you'd build fractional reserve banking on top of Bitcoins).

Re:Japan Starts to Recharge After Two Lost Economic Decades by bdcs on Monday May 20, 2013 @05:21AM (#5736700)
Thank you for the reply. I don't believe I took the quote out of context, as I wrote what Friedman said, almost verbatim without commentary. The monetary base is the stuff consumers touch because -- literally -- if you're touching it, then it is monetary base (cash, etc).

> there is no fractional reserve banking in Bitcoins (or at least I'm not clear how you'd build fractional reserve banking on top of Bitcoins).

Fractional reserve banking with bitcoins works exactly the same as it does with anything else (modern USD, USD 110 years ago [gold-backed], etc.)

Friedman explicitly says, keep the amount of currency constant, and use fractional reserve to increase the amount of monetary supply, as needed for expansion. We can do exactly this with bitcoin. Do you disagree?

Re:Japan Starts to Recharge After Two Lost Economic Decades by apu on Monday May 20, 2013 @08:27PM (#5741160)
I don't believe I took the quote out of context, as I wrote what Friedman said, almost verbatim without commentary.

"Out of context" means you omitted other text that changes the meaning of the text you did quote. See rayiner's comment about this (the very next paragraph...)

The monetary base is the stuff consumers touch

No, it is not. See the wikipedia link and Rayiner's comment, which explicitly refutes this (The monetary base must not be confused with the money supply which consists of currency circulating in the public)

It is hard to take your arguments on good-faith if you make such blatantly false statements.

Re:Japan Starts to Recharge After Two Lost Economic Decades by bdcs on Saturday May 25, 2013 @07:33PM (#5769321)
Milton Friedman meant monetary base, in your nomenclature. From Wikipedia's "Money Supply" article:

"MB: is referred to as the monetary base or total currency. This is the base from which other forms of money (like checking deposits, listed below) are created and is traditionally the most liquid measure of the money supply."

Please reread that last sentence before replying.

Re:Japan Starts to Recharge After Two Lost Economic Decades by ekianjo on Monday May 20, 2013 @12:08AM (#5735815)
Care to explain your thought a little more? Bitcoin as a decentralized currency and a centralized bank in Japan is not really comparable.
Re:Japan Starts to Recharge After Two Lost Economic Decades by rayiner on Monday May 20, 2013 @12:11AM (#5735827)
That distinction is irrelevant. Decentralized or not, Bitcoin is an inherently deflationary currency, and deflationary currencies are bad for the reasons you can see by observing Japan. Deflationary currencies create an extreme incentive to save, since your money will be worth more tomorrow than it is today, which suppresses what really makes an economy move: spending and investing. Whether it's centralized bank policy or an algorithm that causes the deflation is an irrelevant distinction.

The idea that money has intrinsic value or should have intrinsic value is poisonous. Money is just a proxy for goods and services, and the only point of money is to facilitate getting everyone to engage in productive activity. Encouraging people to park money in a digital wallet because it will be worth more tomorrow is the last thing you want.

Japan's famous savings rate was actually one of the causes of its problems in the last couple of decades: http://aparc.stanford.edu/research/causes_of_japans_economic... ("Surplus in Savings: Japan has traditionally enjoyed an unusually high savings rate and a comparatively low consumption rate. During the decades of recovery and high-speed growth, this 'savings surplus' supplied sorely needed capital to private industry in the form of bank loans. This money was used to build and expand Japan's industrial infrastructure and to achieve the rank of a world-class manufacturing power. However, during the 1990s, the 'savings surplus', once the indispensable fuel for high-speed growth, became a serious, structural impediment, leading to a severe slump in demand and causing a heavy drag on Japan's economic recovery.")

Re:Japan Starts to Recharge After Two Lost Economic Decades by handrake on Monday May 20, 2013 @12:18AM (#5735851)
Exactly. I've been wondering why Bitcoin wasn't taking off on the consumer side but I think I now understand. Sadly, by its inherent structure, Bitcoin will never take off as a good means of exchange as real currencies do.
Re:Japan Starts to Recharge After Two Lost Economic Decades by ekianjo on Monday May 20, 2013 @02:44AM (#5736257)
Where is the incentive to save in Japan? Interest rates in banks at like 0.25% here, in case you have not noticed. You are LOSING money when you put it in the bank in Japan, since there's always some level of inflation.
Re:Japan Starts to Recharge After Two Lost Economic Decades by rayiner on Monday May 20, 2013 @02:55AM (#5736287)
There isn't always some level of inflation. Japan has averaged 1.3% per year of deflation over the last decade and a half (http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-22299450). I.e. you get risk free return just putting money under your mattress.