Ten people is an outpost, not a colony, but your point that we should also be working on impactor defense is well-taken. In fact, colonies along with impactor defense is an example of the concept of "defense in depth".
Well, you know what I mean. Even if you had 1000, it would still look pretty bad for the billions of people living on Earth. And let's not talk about genetic diversity in a population of 1000, oh no, let's not talk about that.
EDIT: since you modified your post. Well, agree with you. Just like everyone here should have good offline and online backup strategies for their data.
I know this is what they are pushing to congress now, and I think it isn't a bad idea to do what we can to defend ourselves, but terraforming is where it is at. We need to be able to terraform and colonize places outside of Earth to survive long-term. Unless you start with 10 guys off-planet you'll never get to a million, or a billion, or...
ANd anyway I seriously doubt people living on Earth are going to be OK with their politician telling them: "Oh, there's a huge boulder coming our way, but don't worry! The Human race is safe, we have 10 guys and women living on Mercury! Aren't you glad we planned for this?".