News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Former Google Exec Turns Whistleblower On Company’s Tax A... by sokoloff on Sunday May 19, 2013 @08:20PM (#5735083)
Take a counterfactual: suppose Starbucks isn't in the UK yet, and an enterprising young lad wants to bring it there.

Starbucks might license their name, supply chain and coffee brewing methods to this young lad in exchange for a royalty on each cup sold.

Young lad becomes successful, Starbucks is more successful and now the taxman comes. Suppose YL is charging 4£ for each cup and paying a 3£ royalty. YL is English, selling in England, to English, using English money and English banks. Shall we charge him tax on the whole 4£, minus his in-country expenses? Or shall we charge him tax only on his profits, treating the 3£ royalty as a legitimate business expense, and in fact, the very cornerstone of his business?

Maybe you think YL should pay taxes on it all, but I don't. And I don't begrudge the companies who have structured their affairs wisely, optimally and legally.

Re:Former Google Exec Turns Whistleblower On Company’s Tax A... by CaptainZapp on Sunday May 19, 2013 @10:52PM (#5735579)
The huge hole in your analogy is that the coffee is not sold by YL, but by a fully owned Starbucks subsidiary.

And it's Starbucks corporate that relentlessly games the system, adjusts the licencing fees and defines the licensor (all owned by the very same company) in order to minimize tax.

That makes the 3 quid licece fee not really a legitimate business expense, but a sham. Set up in order not to pay taxes.

Legal? Sure. Honest, fair and decent? Most certainly not.

With all the anger, the austerity and the countries waking up to such shenigans I wonder how much longer such dodgy schemes will work anyway and I have a hunch the clampdown will be very, very hard.

At least I hope so.

Re:Former Google Exec Turns Whistleblower On Company’s Tax A... by DanBC on Monday May 20, 2013 @08:05AM (#5737150)
They tell investors that the business is profitable. They tell the tax office that the business makes no profit.

(http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/10/15/us-britain-starbuc...)

Over 14 years they've made £3bn in revenue, but paid £8.6m corporation tax. (And none for the last 3 years that records are available).

The combination of telling investors that the UK operation is the best performing of the European operations while telling the tax office that there is no profit made in the UK is a distortion of truth that's hard to reconcile.

Starbucks buys beans. They roast those beans. They then sell those beans back to themselves for much more than the market value of roasted beans. That's not because they use good beans, that's a tax dodge. Starbucks thinks it's legal. But investigative authorities don't have the time nor money to go through the accounts to check.

(http://www.reuters.com/article/2012/10/15/us-britain-starbuc...)

(http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/12/02/starbucks-tax-uk_n_...)

Re:Former Google Exec Turns Whistleblower On Company’s Tax A... by lsaferite on Monday May 20, 2013 @08:57AM (#5737426)
Perhaps the disparity is that the business reporting to UK authorities is the subsidiary subject to UK tax law and technically a licensee of the main Starbucks corporation which reports record profits from it's licensing operations to the UK licensee.
Re:Former Google Exec Turns Whistleblower On Company’s Tax A... by ryguytilidie on Sunday May 19, 2013 @10:19PM (#5735475)
"And I don't begrudge the companies who have structured their affairs wisely, optimally and legally."

This argument only works so well when hundreds of millions of dollars a year are paid by these companies to the people who make these laws...Seems a bit naive to overlook that and simply say "well as long as its legal I have no issues with it!"