Programmer Autonomy is a $1 Trillion Issue: http://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/2012/11/25/programmer-au...
The cultural war on closed allocation is the only trillion-dollar problem in the world that I have any power whatsoever to influence (not much, but I have a voice). Attacking Google-- exposing its closed allocation as a catastrophe that destroyed what could have been an amazing company-- is part of the campaign.
How to structure a software workplace properly is the only trillion-dollar issue on which I'm a world-class expert, and probably the only such one in my life. So yes, I do tend to be a bit overfocused on that problem domain.
What is the evidence that you are a world-class expert on that or on any other issue?
I'm sure there are a couple people who know more than I do-- perhaps the CEO of Valve and that company's chief economist-- but it's pretty obvious that I'm on the short list right now. When it comes to setting up the culture for a technology company, I'm one of the few people who actually knows how to do it right.
Kind of reminded me of Zuckerberg's quote: "I don't really need any money. And anyway, I don't think I'm ever going to have an idea this good again."
What I thought was interesting was that the blog post said that a sense of mission and personal autonomy was key, which sure sounds like it would feed into Michael's crusade for open allocation.
But then Googlers post here and seem to say that Google doesn't actually rank those traits highly. Which seems to back up his point.
I don't know the truth of it, and don't really care very much since I don't plan to work at Google, but it's an interesting discussion nonetheless.
It took me into my late 20s to realize that it wasn't Google that was so great but that its marketing department was fantastic. Same for the horrible startup (executive ethics far worse than at Google) where I worked after the Big G.
Perfectly mirrors my experience. Out of college you mostly hear about the big tech companies and trendy startups.
“All people decisions at Google are based on data and analytics,” according to Kathryn Dekas, a manager in Google’s “people analytics” team.
Calibration scores are not fucking data, not any more than bathroom graffiti contains reliable information. Data-driven my ass.
(She may have been only talking about hiring, but she said "all people decisions", and that's incorrect.)
Google discovered that its most innovative workers “are those who have a strong sense of mission about their work and who also feel that they have much personal autonomy.”
Bullshit. Take that attitude to work at a place like Google and you'll be on a PIP as soon as your boss catches wind that you have ambitions other than serving his specific career goals. Google hasn't valued "personal autonomy" since I was in high school.