News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:UK MP to Google: 'you do do evil' when it comes to tax by grey-area on Friday May 17, 2013 @10:25AM (#5724505)
Google's position seems to be that no matter how much of their business is conducted in the UK, as long as they send any money received through a tax haven, they are not liable for tax for their activities there. That is an absurd interpretation of the tax rules, and the logical endpoint of this thinking would be that no country in the world would receive any corporation tax save one, since all sales could be instantly sent through the lowest tax country, regardless of where they are actually processed, booked, or who they are sold to.

So the debate is whether what Google is doing is legal, or whether they are misrepresenting their position in saying that they don't conduct this business in the UK. Having watched the exchange, I'm inclined to say that Google are dissembling and trying to hide the truth about their activities in the UK in an attempt to pay no tax. Here is the head of Google's North European sales, based in Britain of course, claiming that Google's sales are dealt with in Ireland:

http://www.guardian.co.uk/technology/2013/may/16/google-told...

I do think the UK should clarify the tax laws to deal with this and make it clear that where a sale was booked and who deals with the clients is more important than which offshore shell corporation it was shuffled through. At present Google seem to be saying that doesn't matter.

Something similar happend over VAT evasion by Amazon recently, and they have been obliged to start paying VAT, so it's perfectly possible for them to do this and these interviews are part of a long investigation by HMRC. Shell companies are a serious problem for all tax regimes, and it's only going to get worse as globalisation spreads and moving companies becomes easier.

As to your comment on whether governments spend intelligently, there's no discount on taxes (and rightly so) depending on whether you agree with the current government or their spending decisions. Spending priorities is a debate which should be had separately from whether corporations should pay tax at all.

There are no comments on this comment yet.