Re:UK MP to Google: 'you do do evil' when it comes to tax
by icebraining on Friday May 17, 2013 @09:51AM
(#5724304)
When someone drives a car they're polluting, and therefore reducing the quality of life for at least some of the population. Does that mean driving cars is immoral?
Surely something more is needed to make it immoral.
Re:UK MP to Google: 'you do do evil' when it comes to tax
by SEMW on Friday May 17, 2013 @10:07AM
(#5724398)
> Surely something more is needed to make it immoral.
Depends what you mean by immoral.
A moral consequentialist might argue that negative externalities (like pollution) are inherently immoral - though that doesn't necessarily mean every activity with negative externalities is necessarily immoral, since its positive consequences might outweigh that.
Re:UK MP to Google: 'you do do evil' when it comes to tax
by icebraining on Friday May 17, 2013 @10:11AM
(#5724429)
Sure, but I'm not trying to define an absolute moral rule (I don't think the concept even makes sense), I'm arguing with threeseed on what s/he thinks is immoral.
Re:UK MP to Google: 'you do do evil' when it comes to tax
by anon1385 on Friday May 17, 2013 @10:02AM
(#5724365)
>Does that mean driving cars is immoral?
Yes.
Re:UK MP to Google: 'you do do evil' when it comes to tax
by icebraining on Friday May 17, 2013 @10:06AM
(#5724389)
What about polluting by using electricity by posting on HN? ;)
Ultimately paying taxes IS a moral issue since at least some of the money will be used to pay for human services i.e. health, education. And so when companies deliberately avoid paying taxes it does in a small way equate to a reduction in the quality of life for at least some of the population.