News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by michaelochurch on Thursday May 16, 2013 @03:33PM (#5720618)
Well, now the company that treated me like human garbage for pointing out a doomed product direction will, at least, have to view me as human garbage that was right. Progress, one day at a time.

(My idea that was that we should engage independent developers and provide the resources to integrate them with Hangouts, thus having a double win because we'd both (a) get people comfortable with Hangouts and (b) have a higher quality of games than if we published Zynga dreck.)

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by jmillikin on Thursday May 16, 2013 @04:40PM (#5721012)

  > Well, now the company that treated me like human garbage
  > for pointing out a doomed product direction will, at
  > least, have to view me as human garbage that was right.
Your manifestos were treated with astonishing patience and consideration, given their content and your reaction to criticism.

As I recall, your position was that Google+ Games should prefer intricate rulesets based on obscure board- and card-games on the basis that popular casual games are not sufficiently complex to pose an intellectual challenge.

It seems unlikely that positioning Google+ Games as the place to go for half-baked Catan knockoffs would have made it more popular.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by obviouslygreen on Thursday May 16, 2013 @05:36PM (#5721332)
Which is not helped by a follow-up of "the most interesting thing about this news item (or, at least, the only thing worth my time to comment on) is that I was correct, generally speaking, and shall now espouse my belief that I'm owed recognition for it."
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by bdowney on Thursday May 16, 2013 @06:05PM (#5721492)
And still is really sad that Google employees still waste time creating memes about Michael in their stupid internal memegen site many months after his departure.
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by StavrosK on Thursday May 16, 2013 @06:58PM (#5721742)
I'm getting a weird feeling that these guys know something I don't...
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by varelse on Thursday May 16, 2013 @06:52PM (#5721719)
Sometimes Google can be a lot like Heathers with Wynona Ryder's character played by Jon Heder...
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by 1010011010 on Friday May 24, 2013 @02:43PM (#5764602)
... says a person impersonating bdowney
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by michaelochurch on Thursday May 16, 2013 @06:18PM (#5721550)
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by yid on Thursday May 16, 2013 @08:42PM (#5722118)
Since you seem to be an Ayn Rand fan, this is more like it:

Toohey: "Mr. Roark, we’re alone here. Why don’t you tell me what you think of me? In any words you wish. No one will hear us."

Roark: "But I don’t think of you."

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by michaelochurch on Thursday May 16, 2013 @09:57PM (#5722315)
I'm not an Ayn Rand fan, but thanks.

My Atlas Shrugged post was all about how the concept, while appealing, wouldn't work.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by yid on Thursday May 16, 2013 @04:57PM (#5721091)
I have no idea about your past, and I try to read your posts with an open mind, but it's starting to sound increasingly like you have a severe persecution complex. The entire company treated you like "human garbage" and didn't appreciate your gifts? Isn't that a little hyperbolic?

Part of the challenge in working with large groups of people is convincing them that your ideas have merit. That's not unique to Google or any company -- that's just the psychology of social interactions. It sounds like you have an unreasonable expectation that everyone bow down immediately and unquestioningly to your opinions, and leads me to wonder if you have delusions of your own grandeur.

Learning how to interact with people seems to be a skill that you have not acquired, and it certainly makes me want to never work with you.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by michaelochurch on Thursday May 16, 2013 @05:10PM (#5721170)
See, I neither want nor expect anyone to "unquestioningly" listen to my opinions and ideas. That would be a disaster. I have a lot of good ideas, but I have some bad ones too.

What I can't stand is when people don't make the fucking effort to reach the right idea, but just fall back on rank. That will make me very angry.

If they'd given me an explanation of why my idea wouldn't work or why they had to do things a certain way, I would have been happy with that. They could have brought me into a few of the meetings so I'd see how the sausage is made, and maybe I'd realize some of the constraints they were under and see why my idea wouldn't work in that context.

I do, however, expect to be treated as an equal, and I'll raise hell if I'm not. That doesn't mean my ideas are taken without question. Shit, how could anyone even want that? The yes-man behavior (taking someones' ideas without question) isn't respectful; it sets a person up for future embarrassment.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by yid on Thursday May 16, 2013 @05:24PM (#5721247)
Interesting, your comment didn't do much to change my initial impression. Allow me to explain why, and I mean this as hopefully constructive criticism:

> What I can't stand is when people don't make the fucking effort to reach the right idea, but just fall back on rank. That will make me very angry.

Optimal decisions are rarely made by groups of people, which is part of the challenge of working with people. It's understandably upsetting, but if this bothers you so much, you should consider: (a) changing jobs if the person pulling rank is unreasonable, or (b) working out the power structure and on your relationships and communication to get your point across better.

> They could have brought me into a few of the meetings so I'd see how the sausage is made, and maybe I'd realize some of the constraints they were under and see why my idea wouldn't work in that context.

It sounds like you were cut out of the decision-making process. Perhaps your superiors were genuinely unreasonable, in which case you should have done what everyone in an unreasonable work situation should do: switch teams, or switch jobs. Alternatively, if your real-world interactions convey as much arrogance and petulance as your online rants do, then you're maybe losing out because people don't find it productive to bring you into the decision-making process. Perhaps you're right, but perhaps the way you communicate turns people off. I'm just laying out some alternate possibilities, since your posts seem to convey that everyone was against you.

> I do, however, expect to be treated as an equal, and I'll raise hell if I'm not.

Perhaps you're not earning peoples' respect with this attitude. It sounds a bit like what my 5-year-old does when he thinks we're being unfair to him.

EDIT: You're obviously intelligent, but you have to realize that there are other intelligent people, and all things being equal, most people would rather work with someone who can communicate.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by michaelochurch on Thursday May 16, 2013 @05:51PM (#5721411)
I hope it's obvious that when I proposed the idea, I did not do so with the anger that I am showing now.

Also, I'm not that angry about the mishandling of G+ Games. I wasn't even on that team, so it's not a big deal. That's just one symptom of an underlying problem, which is the dishonesty that exists when a company is marketed as open and engineer-centric but was taken over by managers several years ago.

Google is a bank with worse pay. If it admitted as much-- you'll be working in a closed-allocation environment, because we're now a bank-- I would fully respect that.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by untog on Thursday May 16, 2013 @05:13PM (#5721183)
You write some great posts on HN, but every time Google is so much as mentioned you descend into this same persecution complex. I wish you wouldn't, but I'll try to talk about this in generalities:

"Ha, my negativity has been vindicated by failure!" is never a good public stance to take. Not for you, nor for the people who disagreed with you. It is a victory for you, but it's one to internalise. The people who were there and complete strangers will think less or you for gloating otherwise. Know that you were right, apply the lesson in the future.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by tptacek on Thursday May 16, 2013 @04:14PM (#5720870)
Apropos nothing: as many readers of my own comments will happily attest, it is easy to both be right and behave like "human garbage" (or whatever non-hyperbolic term you'd like to substitute for that one).
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by jmillikin on Thursday May 16, 2013 @04:33PM (#5720975)
One important contrast with the OP is that although your posts are sometimes blunt, they are almost always cogent and well-argued.
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by waterlesscloud on Thursday May 16, 2013 @05:09PM (#5721161)
One of the most difficult (but most rewarding) tricks to learn is to separate the merit of an argument from the manner in which it is expressed.
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by gfodor on Thursday May 16, 2013 @05:22PM (#5721235)
A better trick is to present your argument so your audience does not need to have mastered a trick of its own.
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by metaphorm on Thursday May 16, 2013 @05:51PM (#5721413)
well now, that is a truly unpleasant level of self-righteousness and resentment.
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by michaelochurch on Thursday May 16, 2013 @05:56PM (#5721444)
My manager at Google had a 5-year-long history of using fake performance problems to tease out peoples' health issues, and then using that information to fuck with them. (For one case, there's a year-long record of meetings moved to conflict with therapy sessions.) HR did absolutely nothing about him because he had a reputation for "delivering" in spite of his known sadistic behavior. (I spent months investigating this shit, and went places I didn't belong.)

Oh, and Google is one of those stuck-up companies where if you get a bad performance review, you can never move to another project.

It finally ended up being up to me to expose that manager (which I did after finding my next job) and when I did, I experienced some extremely unprofessional attacks. Someone (possibly my ex-manager) found out where my next job was and called in a hit.

Given that, I'm justified in enjoying Google's stumbles.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by metaphorm on Thursday May 16, 2013 @05:59PM (#5721462)
just move on. I'm sorry you were treated badly by your manager. taking it out with public tantrums doesn't make you look like the good guy though.
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by michaelochurch on Thursday May 16, 2013 @06:08PM (#5721508)
If this were just about me being unlucky, I'd be able to do that.

The problem is that these things are common. They happen all the time, and they keep happening to people all over the place, and nothing is done to these fuckers. That's what makes me fucking angry.

The guy pulled that shit for years and HR not only did nothing, but repeatedly kept people from moving away from him. Same story, five fucking years, over and over, and they did nothing.

One bad manager is just life. A company that deliberately allows them to thrive for supposed project expediency gains has no right to use the motto: Don't Be Evil.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by varelse on Thursday May 16, 2013 @08:50PM (#5722147)
I had a bad manager at google too thanks to the wonders of blind allocation. And I have vented about that experience several times on here. It was cathartic, and now it's out of me. But the price of doing so is that I'll probably never be able to get a job there again. Still, there are far worse things that can happen in life.

So as someone who went through something similar after diving headfirst into the Googleplex without a helmet, can I suggest that you really ought to move on for your own good and let karma eventually catch up with these guys?

It's magical what they'll do to themselves in the long run - it just takes time. I already saw one round of comeuppances after the dotcom boom. It really works because eventually they cross the wrong person at the right time and the universe balances the equation all on its own.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by michaelochurch on Thursday May 16, 2013 @10:02PM (#5722328)
So as someone who went through something similar after diving headfirst into the Googleplex without a helmet, can I suggest that you really ought to move on for your own good and let karma eventually catch up with these guys?

The problem is that the career system (especially in software, which has this hypocritical sense of itself as a meritocracy) is the most elaborate system of victim-shaming ever devised.

I'm almost 30 and my IQ is over 150. I should be an EIR or doing cutting-edge machine learning work, and I'm not, because I was robbed by those fuckers.

Yes, they'll get their comeuppances. I'm sure they'll fall into the wrong fight. But I suffer every day from what those pieces of shit stole from me. I'm years behind where a person at my level of talent should be. Some of it is my fault, some of it is not, but the rest of the world sees it as 100% a reflection on me.

Work is the only society in which being robbed is treated as 100% the victim's fault. If your boss steals from you by giving you shitty work experience and then ruining your career, you are the subhuman piece of shit that deserves to die, not him.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by gazrogers on Friday May 17, 2013 @06:26AM (#5723516)
You're not even 30 and you're speaking as though your career is over and your chances of ever doing cutting edge stuff are gone. Your life is to a certain extent what you make it. Stop looking back at the crap times with regret otherwise you'll end up a bitter old man.

And stop thinking that your IQ entitles you to anything. I scored 175 on an IQ test (Cattell III B - probably equivalent to 147 on the test you took) and I work doing CRUD apps for an insurance broker for $40000. I'll never work for Google or a company like that much as I'd love to. Your IQ test score is nice - and great for showing off - but it doesn't entitle you to anything. You need to earn your career.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by varelse on Thursday May 16, 2013 @10:55PM (#5722471)
When I was 30, I was making a tenth of what I'm making now and in the middle of destroying my career by exposing faked data in the wonderful world of science. You think Google is bad? Try getting threatened by a prominent member of the National Academy of Science because you caught him red-handed.

Needless to say, I was very successful at destroying my career. But much like the guy who got turned into a newt, I got better.

You're going to live past 100 assuming you don't get hit by a truck or an asteroid, the game's barely started. Go do something amazing that no one else could have done, by hook or by crook, and whatever happened in the past will be forgotten overnight.

But above all, don't be a victim. Even if you are a victim, don't be one.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by philsnow on Monday May 20, 2013 @04:52PM (#5739965)
> You're going to live past 100 assuming you don't get hit by a truck or an asteroid, the game's barely started. Go do something amazing that no one else could have done, by hook or by crook, and whatever happened in the past will be forgotten overnight.

As I recall, he was given almost exactly this advice when he was having his meltdown at Google, except s/live past 100/become a productive employee/ . It didn't seem to help.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by thehammy on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @05:35PM (#5782982)
I've known plenty of smart people who didn't get anywhere in their career. Why? Lots of different reasons, ranging from personality, lack of communication skills, entitlement issues, lack of self control, etc. Sometimes all of those reasons.

If you are in a tough spot in your career, try to be honest with yourself about how/where you can improve, and make an effort to improve. At 30, it sounds like you are looking for instant gratification.

My recommendation: stop getting on these boards talking negatively and using profanity. It's not helping. Start bringing relevant insight and commentary that highlights your skills. Be open to constructive feedback from friends and colleagues. Work to improve. It may take a few years to rebuild - but think of it this way: 5 years is an eternity in the tech world. If you do things right for 5 years you may have an entirely different outlook.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by cosisin on Monday May 27, 2013 @05:24AM (#5774016)
A company that deliberately allows them to thrive for supposed project expediency gains has no right to use the motto: Don't Be Evil.

"Don't Be Evil" is such a conflated concept at Google. It sounds that you were fooled by it. Get real. Google's primary goal is to benefit itself. Good news [for users] is that benefiting the user is usually what benefits Google the most. Righting wrongs in HR issues that would expose Google as an employer to potential lawsuit liabilities and negative PR is not. Don't be so fucking idealistic.

Does shit happens deliberately? No, it's just the law of large numbers at Google's size today. However, covering up the shit is sometimes rational and evolutionary. How many start-ups die because they don't deal with HR issues the "right" way?

You were unlucky, but you also lack the tact to deal with your situation. Your years of experience and your 150 IQ didn't help, so what makes you think you would fare better as an EIR?

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by mobius99 on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @03:43AM (#5778728)
I'm not sure the law of large numbers means what you think it means.
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by justkelly_ on Tuesday May 28, 2013 @04:18PM (#5782467)
You worked at Google for five months. How did that possibly destroy your career?
Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by illuminate on Friday May 17, 2013 @02:31PM (#5725970)
"If this were just about me being unlucky, I'd be able to do that."

Exactly, this is you being unlucky and constantly throwing yourself under any bus-like object that crosses your path.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by EvanKelly on Thursday May 16, 2013 @06:02PM (#5721477)
Can you clarify what "called in a hit" means?

I'm not exactly in the tech community, so I'm hoping it means something different than my understanding.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by michaelochurch on Thursday May 16, 2013 @06:34PM (#5721625)
It means "tried to fuck up my next job".

Working for Google was, by far, the biggest mistake I've ever made in my life. No question about that.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by illuminate on Thursday May 16, 2013 @10:51PM (#5722457)
"one of those stuck-up companies where if you get a bad performance review, you can never move to another project"

Ah yes, putting the employee on "probation" and awaiting any reason to let them go.

Re:Google+ Games is shutting down by Mz on Thursday May 16, 2013 @11:10PM (#5722500)
No, they don't actually have to "view you as right," even if you absolutely were.

Intended as helpful: What is the point of your screed here? What do you think it will do for you? What are you trying to accomplish?

People who are awful to you are highly unlikely to own up, apologize, make amends...etc.. Life rarely works that way.

Not trying to make your life harder. I have done some venting myself on HN at times.