News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Driving students into science is a fool's errand by michaelochurch on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @05:26PM (#5715070)
There are two potential labor market realities and we still don't know, as a society, which one is right:

1. Labor finitism: there's a fairly fixed amount of labor that society will pay money for, and us proles are doomed to compete against each other for it, in what ultimately becomes a race to the bottom.

2. Labor progressivism: technical and scientific progress will free up resources for more interesting and higher-yield work, and make everyone richer. To quote Keynes, the rising tide will lift all boats.

In a labor-finitist world, the worker's job is to extract as much payment out of capital-holders (for as little work) as possible. The labor-finitist world is almost Malthusian in its ruthless cruelty. In a labor-progressivist world, it's actually good to do the grunt work quickly, so you can graduate to more interesting stuff.

Of course, reality is somewhere between these two extremes. In the very short term, it's labor finitist: people have to formally "create" jobs. In the long term, it's labor progressivist; the labor pool does expand, with its rate being an open question. The open question pertains to the 0.1-20 years range over which we actually make career decisions. It's like Efficient Market Hypothesis, whose truth comes down to "what time frame?" (Over very-short or very-long timeframes, EMH is demonstrably not true for well-known reasons. Over typical timeframes, it is.)

If labor finitism is true, then we want to drive young people far away from whatever we do. Given that the software industry is already a horrible place to work, just being honest about the low autonomy and shitty legacy code and arrogance of non-technical management-- also, the fact that, even though our salaries might look good on paper, we make about 1/5 of what we should given the bullshit we have to put up with-- ought to be enough. We just need to counteract the Googley propaganda about this career involving actual autonomy and respect.

If labor progressivism is true, then since science and technology are the driving forces of that progress, we want as many people in those industries as have the talent, because that will bring us out of scarcity faster.

It's unclear which is the case, though. Labor progressivism is true in the underlying "real world", but this society is littered with legacy power relationships that, I'm afraid, make labor finitism a lot more accurate. Just look at the terrorist attack that has been inflicted on the academic job market for the past 25 years if you don't believe that.

Re:Driving students into science is a fool's errand by toby on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @06:03PM (#5715294)
"Given that the software industry is already a horrible place to work"

You say things like this a lot. I'm willing to accept that I may be naive, but do you think that those of us who have had primarily positive experiences (and I know a few, not only me) just incredibly lucky?

I've been a programmer for 13 years and have worked at failing startups, moderately successful startups and big companies. I've mostly coded but have also managed small groups. There's some amount of bullshit in every job, I think, but I haven't found it to be disproportionate compared to my friends in other industries.

Re:Driving students into science is a fool's errand by michaelochurch on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @08:54PM (#5716172)
I don't know what you've experienced. Maybe you've been unusually lucky. Perhaps I've been unlucky. But everything I've seen convinces me that shitty experiences are the norm in this industry.

I enjoy programming and solving hard problems, but I hate this industry with a passion. I'm sick of the terrible legacy code, the bad decisions made by people dumber than a crocodile's fecal product, and the lack of respect and autonomy for the people doing the actual fucking work.

Even Google turned itself into a closed-allocation shitpile at some point. What a fucking disaster.

We've failed to make ourselves a real profession, and it seems like the norm is for us to suffer dearly for it. Most programmers live in an environment where they have minimal autonomy and don't even choose which projects they work on. It's fucking disgusting and if we had any collective self-respect, we'd demolish the assholes who built these horrible work environments.

Personally, I won't be happy until the people who instituted calibration scores and closed allocation at Google commit seppuku. They destroyed billions of dollars worth of economic value, they ruined the lives of hundreds to thousands of highly talented people, and it's the only decent thing for them to do after that.

Re:Driving students into science is a fool's errand by TheAntipodean on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:38AM (#5717253)
In an effort to find out what closed allocation meant I fired up your favourite search engine, Google, and searched the term. I was amused to see an article on your blog come up as the top hit.
Re:Driving students into science is a fool's errand by michaelochurch on Thursday May 16, 2013 @08:18AM (#5718177)
I have no problem with the search engine Google. I still use it-- and Gmail, too.

At least 90% of the people at Google are really solid. Good people, great engineers. I have a dislike for the management, not the people or the products.

Re:Driving students into science is a fool's errand by ableal on Saturday May 18, 2013 @04:47AM (#5728299)
Interesting, thought provoking posts, but you seem to have used two different tags that pop up in search:

http://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/tag/project-allocation/ (the Discomfort is Bad piece)

http://michaelochurch.wordpress.com/tag/closed-allocation/ (the earlier Only Real Option piece)

There's also the more systematic Quora/Forbes piece: http://www.forbes.com/sites/quora/2012/11/26/what-is-open-al...

Re:Driving students into science is a fool's errand by ArtB on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @08:58PM (#5716191)
> You say things like this a lot. I'm willing to accept that I may be naive, but do you think that those of us who have had primarily positive experiences (and I know a few, not only me) just incredibly lucky?

Do you live in a major tech hub? Because here a lot of the jobs suck and we take the only gigs in town and most of us are the victims of the "two body problem" with more successful spouses anchoring us to undesirable areas.

Re:Driving students into science is a fool's errand by kyllo on Thursday May 16, 2013 @02:06AM (#5717165)
Here's to hoping that we as a society have the good sense to decide to reduce the barriers to entry for freelancing and entrepreneurship, so that anyone with skills can simply create their own job and trade their labor freely--without having to worry about "benefits" because the government actually provides those like it's supposed to.
Re:Driving students into science is a fool's errand by Retric on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @07:48PM (#5715888)
One of the large issues with the US educational system is it's largely driven by the choices made by teenagers. Sure, some people go back and study high school level math later in life but few high school dropouts end up getting a Math PHD. From an economic perspective an oversupply of chemists is simply more useful than an oversupply of historians. Thus, it seems reasonable to try and convince 15 year olds that STEM is worth the time investment over playing video games. So, they may end up working at Walmart anyway, but skills you don't use are a minor problem compared to skills you need and don't have.