Re:Airline industry divided over passenger electronics
by gnaffle on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @04:06PM
(#5714496)
There are two assumptions that people in these discussion make
1) If 30% of the passengers leave their devices on today, leaving 100% of the devices on won't cause any increase in problems, and
2) If something happens it's either a) nothing, or b) the airplane falls out of the sky.
The fact is that an airplane is an incredibly complex machine. Instrument failures happen all the time, and pilots deal with this (they have redundant instruments and alternate procedures they can follow). If some of these problems happen due to interference from electronic devices, that's pretty much impossible to verify.
Why do I think it's safe? Because rules don't control reality, only people's behaviors do. In reality, we fly with our electronics on every single large flight, and they are not crashing or experiencing any particular problems. The only reason the rules are still there is that nobody wants to run the risk of being the one who gets blamed for some problem, because after some crash or something, somebody else who labors under the delusion that the rules actually mean something will pin the blame on the electronic devices, falsely, and by extension, the one who lifted the rules.
That's it. That's the only thing keeping this rule in place. It sure isn't physics. I don't have to be an EE or anything else, we've run this experiments hundreds of thousands or millions of times already.
That said, your little planes may have their own issues and this experience may not apply to your plane. But we're talking commercial flights here.