Likewise, in places where wages are higher it appears to be mostly about cost of living. The last time I calculated it out making 50k in the armpit of nowhere USA turned out pretty close overall to making 75 or 80k in SF or NY with taxes, commute time, and cost of living factored in.
Quite a bit above $100K too, and I don't even consider myself a guru/ninja/pirate/whatever programmer either.
I'm not alone either - literally every programmer I keep in regular touch with, and literally every programmer at the shop I work at is making well into the $100s. In fact, a good friend of mine the same age as me (mid-20s) just accepted an offer in the $180s.
The cost of living argument is also mostly bull. I've lived and worked in 7 different cities, ranging from cheap $300 rooms on the wrong side of the tracks to $2000+ luxury high-rises. Nowadays I live in Manhattan, and I've done the math multiple times - it costs me about $20K more per year (with fairly generous numbers) to live here than in, say, Seattle WA where I once worked. Of course, the pay difference between NYC and elsewhere is a lot higher than $20K. Even accounting for taxes, food, and everything you're still coming out well ahead.
I know some of the best developers in my college class have ended up getting paid 45k to 65k a year in places like Phoenix because that's what was available job wise.
I've done the same math from almost everywhere I've ever lived, and both SF and NYC still come out on top. The market salaries in those cities do make up for the cost of living, and then some. The whole "SF and NYC are bullshit because you end up losing money after cost of living adjustment" argument is bull, specifically because the market salaries between it and other cities in the US doesn't bear this out.
> "I know some of the best developers in my college class have ended up getting paid 45k to 65k a year in places like Phoenix because that's what was available job wise."
Sadly, the availability of jobs is not very highly correlated with programming ability. And I say this in a non-snarky way. The top end of the software industry is very much an exercise in pedigreed degrees, networking acumen, and fake-it-till-you-make-it.
We're really not that much better than the business majors we like to make fun of.
My guess? Expensive real-estate all over the world just makes it harder and harder to pay for anything, especially employees you have to relocate. And severe socioeconomic and infrastructural inequality makes it a lot tougher to get out of the "center and periphery" problem.
Here are average US regional tech wages in 2012 according to the TechAmerica Foundation:
California: $123,900
Massachusetts: $116,000
Washington: $110,200
And I know at many companies the average is more like $150,000 and still have a very difficult time hiring software engineers. I doubt most of the public will be sympathetic to claims that the only reason these positions go unfilled is that companies are unwilling to pay an appropriate wage.