News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Female Engineers: Too Fit For The Role by swombat on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @07:03AM (#5711159)
Kind of puts the "sexism in tech" discussion in perspective. These guys make the Mad Men lot sound respectful.

Here's a simple way they could deal with that - create a new company (or even just a new department within the company), hire only civilised people, fire anyone who proves to be an uncivilised jerk, and slowly grow that department/company to take over the company/industry because it's not full of retards...

Re:Female Engineers: Too Fit For The Role by mattdeboard on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @07:41AM (#5711298)
> hire only civilised people, fire anyone who proves to be an uncivilised jerk ... because it's not full of retards...

Complaining about sexism then using "retards" as a pejorative is just too ironic.

Re:Female Engineers: Too Fit For The Role by UnoriginalGuy on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @07:47AM (#5711325)
That caught me off guard too. I didn't realise anyone used the term anymore.

Maybe the OP used it to make a point?

Re:Female Engineers: Too Fit For The Role by swombat on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @09:53AM (#5711926)
I don't call mentally handicapped people retards, I call them mentally handicapped people.

Retards, in my vocabulary, means someone who is not mentally handicapped but is a cretin. I could have used the word "cretin", in fact.

Re:Female Engineers: Too Fit For The Role by UnoriginalGuy on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @10:39AM (#5712269)
So you'd happily use the N' word, "fag," "gay," and similar since you can re-define them in your head to be just general insults, rather than associating negativity with the groups for which these words were originally used?

Sorry but we both know the reason you're using that word is because you want to paint them as being mentally handicapped which you perceive as "bad." You can pretend that isn't what you're doing but even if that is true that is how others perceive it, because when they hear the word "retard" they think mentally handicapped and you're using it as a derogative.

Re:Female Engineers: Too Fit For The Role by swombat on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @11:10AM (#5712487)
Retard does not have the same "inappropriate" connotations in the UK as in the US (certainly it's nothing like using nigger or fag(got) in conversation as a pejorative).

But yes, I do think being mentally handicapped is "bad". Are you arguing that it's "good"?

Re:Female Engineers: Too Fit For The Role by UnoriginalGuy on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @11:30AM (#5712615)
I live here. Yes it does.
Re:Female Engineers: Too Fit For The Role by swombat on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @11:34AM (#5712658)
Well, I live here too. Maybe you live in an alternate reality.

You didn't answer my question. Do you think being mentally handicapped is good?

Re:Female Engineers: Too Fit For The Role by UnoriginalGuy on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @11:42AM (#5712717)
It is neither good nor bad. Neutral.

But regardless of your opinion, using it as an insult is uncalled for. Since essentially you're lumping people who already have problems in with whatever it is you're trying to insult.

Re:Female Engineers: Too Fit For The Role by swombat on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @05:39PM (#5715149)
I think by now we're really arguing semantics, but I would argue that I do not lump anyone in with the people I call retards.

I would never call a mentally handicapped person a "retard". To me, that would be an incredibly insulting and inappropriate thing to do. The only people I'd call retards are people who are not mentally handicapped.

Similarly, if I call someone a dick head, I do not consider that to be insulting, or even related, to physical dick heads... it's just an insulting term. If I call someone (a guy, usually) a bitch (e.g "Yo, bitch, pass me the beer"), that does not imply any connection with female dogs.

Btw, I don't see how you can argue that being mentally handicapped (which by definition means having mental issues) can be neutral. It's clearly a net negative. It doesn't mean the person is more or less good, much like missing a leg or an arm (aka physically handicapped) doesn't make the person more or less good, but it's definitely a "bad" thing.

Re:Female Engineers: Too Fit For The Role by onemorepassword on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @07:33AM (#5711270)
These guys are disrespectful, insulting and pathetic, but at least she got the job and none of the anecdotes suggest they assumed she was incapable of doing that job.

That's already two steps up from Mad Men territory.

And beside the crudeness, which is more a social class difference than anything else, I don't see how this differs from the reports of sexism in tech. At least she's got the (albeit clumsy and inadequate) support of her employer. They weren't advertising job posts for "brogrammers".

Being less crude than construction workers is not exactly a high standard for tech.

Re:Female Engineers: Too Fit For The Role by sp332 on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @07:28AM (#5711247)
The guys (well, some of them) are discussing her treatment behind her back. One of them even apologizes every time he swears in a meeting. That means even the ones who care honestly don't know how women want to be treated in a workplace. (Of course, part of the problem is that they are constructing some kind of universal ruleset without considering her as an individual.)

It seems that no one knew which guys were the jerks before because they acted reasonably when women weren't around. I think the same thing happened in tech circles. There are some major assholes and even creepy stalkers that don't really show themselves until women show up, so they go unnoticed for years by the male majority.

Re:Female Engineers: Too Fit For The Role by treerock on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @08:41AM (#5711551)
I would love it if there was a way of testing these things out. I've a sneaking suspicion (based on absolutely no reason) that the company 'full or retards' would outperform the company of nice, respectful people. But the real world is a big messy place.