Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout
by vidarh on Wednesday May 15, 2013 @05:49AM
(#5710992)
If they "struggle with the same (low) weight for ages" they are not following either SS or SL, as both programs include protocols for deloading to get past sticking points that works, and to eventually changing programs once your progress slows too much. E.g. SL goes from 5x5 to 3x5 to 1x5, to switching off SL entirely and switching to Madcow or Texas Method or similar - this progression is explicitly documented as part of the program, up to and including stopping SL.
SL is by design a beginners routine, intended to exploit quick recovery while you're a beginner. It is intended to get too hard for you to continue to be able to gain on it. Starting your workout with 5x5 squats 3 times a weak is not something normal people will keep doing with heavy weights. Once I started flattening out with SL 5x5, it took <6 months of substantial gains before I was flattening out on 1x5 too, and switched first to Texas Method, then to Wendlers 5/3/1. At the moment I'm doing a program that is similar to 5/3/1 but slightly higher volume, as I'm seeing decent results from that while eating like a pig.
SL is by design a beginners routine, intended to exploit quick recovery while you're a beginner. It is intended to get too hard for you to continue to be able to gain on it. Starting your workout with 5x5 squats 3 times a weak is not something normal people will keep doing with heavy weights. Once I started flattening out with SL 5x5, it took <6 months of substantial gains before I was flattening out on 1x5 too, and switched first to Texas Method, then to Wendlers 5/3/1. At the moment I'm doing a program that is similar to 5/3/1 but slightly higher volume, as I'm seeing decent results from that while eating like a pig.