1. Your summary doesn't even really make sense as a coherent thought. The author actually says that he showed up 8 hours early for a meetup and a friend told him of his mistake. IMO not wasting a lot of time wondering where everyone is is useful.
2. Gabriel never says anything about not being able to remember what he's doing, and your implication that he's a moron is pretty ridiculous. Incidentally, a lot of people use twitter this way.
3. In the article itself he mentions that someone gave a bug report over twitter. Again, this is another common practice. Even if the author hasn't yet found any useful tweets (he has), he undoubtedly will in the future.
4. Your comment is ambiguous. Gabriel mentions that twitter is another tool for communicating with customers. Believe it or not, when people are interested in a product or service they like to get updates about it.
5. Gabriel doesn't use Twitter itself as an ice-breaker, but others' tweets. "Hey, nice to meet you. Yeah I started following you because of what you wrote about ninja turtles. I like ninja turtles too!"
6. ...
7. Completely inaccurate. Author wrote, "I don't really have that many, but with the amount I do have it is enough to get benefit when spreading news and links about my company or otherwise."
Twitter is religion :) Thou shalt not try to convert.
Last question: is there a way to delete HN account?
> So how being corrected for writing what you doing is useful to you?
In the specific example, it saved me hours of time.
> Or feeling of being more connected - is that useful?
Absolutely. It makes me happier and more productive.
> Or repeating your FaceBook status - is that useful?
Absolutely. For the same reason Facebook status' are useful!
> Or spreading links, which you admit to be not working because of not enough followers?
That's not what I said. I said you need a lot of followers to make is useful, and I have about just enough for it to be: "I don't really have that many, but with the amount I do have it is enough..."
We have different beliefs. I'm not planning of convincing you to my point-of-view (it would pretty much be impossible and also useless for me, I'm not running a religion) and your arguments don't convince me.
...convince me that Twitter is more useful than harmful (especially to your time and self-assessment), I'd rather have 1 real-life friend and 1 real-life enemy tell me their opinion about my startup, than any sampling of random 1000 Twitter followers. I might prefer opinion of HN readers (smart guys here), but not the ranks of people reading Kutcher's tweets or things like fart-tweeting chairs. I tried reading the smartest folks, but even they struggle to tell some coherent thought in 140 chars. Then it turns out, those guys aren't really there, but rather ghostwriters. And Shaq. Who as great basketball player as he is - isn't exactly the mastermind. So, who else are Twitting? Oprah. Give me a break.
Twittering is just another way to passively entertain yourself, like TV. Just like TV remote - you have to press a few buttons occasionally and show goes on - a lot of fluff-fluff-fluff, then maybe something useful and then again 59 minutes 45 seconds of fluff. Hardly worth spending hour to go through fluff (commercials in TV case or what your "follower" ate for breakfast or who he's in petty war against who to reach 1M followers in case of Twitter). It's just not worth the time spent.
In my opinion - if you want opinion on your startup.. Add UserVoice. Do you want to promote it? Buy ads or do some smart marketing that doesn't require money. Using Twitter you're just following the herd which spends 99% of their time on useless reading of other peoples... let's call them.. thoughts.. or Re-Thhooughts in many cases.
Once again I remind you that this is my BELIEF and I couldn't convince you of that and you won't convince me of opposite using arguments you presented. So, let's just move our own ways.
Second, this comment is more useful than your first. Even though it's not responding to anything in the actual article, you at least give your opinion and reasons for it. As opposed to writing, "THIS ISN'T USEFUL!!! COME ON!?" Your comment is also useful to me personally because I find twitter useful and seeing your objections to it has caused me to think about and clarify my reasons for appreciating twitter.
And besides, I've always found rude submitting links to his own blog.
WTH?
8 _SPECIFIC_ USEFUL cases mentioned in article:
[1. I joined T. and started talking where I was. I was corrected. Useful!] -incorrect, corrected to "nonrecursive" clarification below, my apologies
2. It can repeat my Facebook status. Now I never forget what I'm doing. Useful!
3. I monitor twitter search about "Duck Duck Go" (the author's startup), which tells me what customer think about it ( http://search.twitter.com/search?q="duck+duck+go" to spare you the time - all tweets are "Trying new search engine", one opinion given, same opinion re-tweetted once more). Useful! (well, this might not be as sarcasctic as others)
4. I don't think you heard about "Duck Duck Go" enough, so here's more....
5. "It helps me meet new people (in person).... it gives you great ice-breakers when you meet people" Twitter?? As a _Great_ ice-breaker??.. Twitter??
(addendum) 5a. "For example, I follow a lot of people ..., but have not yet met all of them in person. " ... Did he meet any of them?
6. It make me feel connected.... (remember it's about _SPECIFIC_ USE CASES, SPECIFIC! USE!)
7. "It helps me spread news/links. You need a decent amount of followers for this one. I don't really have that many" ..........
8. "It helps me keep abreast of news/links" Well... I can believe this one..
Probably the article "1 specific use case Twitter helps me" wouldn't be as popular.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=PN2HAroA12w#t=151s