Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout
by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday May 14, 2013 @06:48PM
(#5708923)
That's a strawman, no one is claiming it is a complete waste of time, only that it is inefficient.
Here is the first sentence from the top comment in this thread.
>This is a waste of time.
He then goes on to explain that the only way to get real and lasting benefits from an exercise routine is to go to the gym and lift weights.
Re:The Scientific 7-Minute Workout
by nazgulnarsil on Tuesday May 14, 2013 @10:28PM
(#5709829)
A waste of time, not a complete waste of time. Inefficiency implies you are wasting time.
I agree that the part about "only real and lasting" is wrong.
If I woke up one day and decided that the most important thing in my life was to one day bench-press 400 lbs, I would grab a copy of Starting Strength and hit the weights. There really isn't any debate about that.
The original argument against bodyweight exercise was that it's a complete waste of time. It clearly isn't. When I started basic training, about 20 percent of us could actually pass a PT test. Some people could only perform a couple of push-ups. After 8-9 weeks of doing nothing but running and body-weight exercise, nearly everyone passed.
If you took a cycle of recruits, tested them on the bench-press on day 1 of basic training, and then did so again on the last day, I'd be willing to bet that on average, their numbers would be significantly higher.