I think "welfare state" is a pretty loaded term, and I think America's economic troubles have almost nothing to do with health care. (Canada, for the record, has had public health care for a long time and our economic troubles are also completely unrelated.)
I actually wasn't necessarily including health care in "welfare state", old age pensions AKA Social Security here are the traditional start (it was Bismarck who set the age at 65, BTW), but of course health care is a big one that gets added later, e.g. for 65 and up in the US in the early-mid '60s. And those supports are a critical part of all this, they tend to destroy the old model, sundering family bonds. The young can say, with complete truth, they're already paying very heavily to support the old, starting when they can least afford it, the parents can say, with much less truth in the long term if the history of government promises are any guide, that the government will take care of them (and in a greater sense, including their money being worth something when they retire).
I also wasn't making a general case about our economic troubles and health care, just pointing out one existential place where the latter are contributing to what well might be the end of US society.
Anyway, the point is that we seem to disagree on who should pay for health care when, and how. That's okay :) Thanks for politely and intelligently sharing your thoughts with me.
For that matter, comparing it with the old model, the demand upon the youth start out much too early. In the US it looks like we might be reaching the tipping point where the young by and large can't afford to start families because the financial burdens placed upon them have grown too large.
Sorry to be harsh, but Canada is at an 1.7 fertility rate (2.1 is break even) and your society is therefore dying out, so your opinion in this area is not necessarily worth very much.