Re:Genetic Algorithms: Evolving Human Faces
by jobeirne on Monday April 20, 2009 @10:32AM
(#570736)
This is not a genetic algorithm; this is a steady-state-ish (MU, LAMBDA) evolution strategies algorithm. Genetic algorithms imply crossover, not simply mutation.
People have gotta stop referring to population-based methods of stochastic search as "genetic algorithms".
Re:Genetic Algorithms: Evolving Human Faces
by lbrandy on Monday April 20, 2009 @10:47AM
(#570767)
Our algorithm is also not a "face detector". It's a feature-based machine-learned image classifier that was trained on faces and non-faces. However, when speaking to those presumably without a background in machine learning, I think "face detector" conveys more information.
Also, the title "Steady-state-ish (MU, LAMBDA) evolution strategies algorithm, and/or population-based stochastic search: Evolving Human Faces" is too long.
Re:Genetic Algorithms: Evolving Human Faces
by jobeirne on Monday April 20, 2009 @11:31AM
(#570852)
Also, this doesn't seem to be an apt analogy; I'm no expert on machine learning (certainly) but it seems to me that "face detector" is simply a catchy abstraction that does not necessarily contradict the underlying technicalities of your production.
My issue with your titling "Genetic Algorithms" is that it is not simply a more convenient, abstract way of expressing what you did: it is in fact a contradiction of terms with the underlying technical details of what you did.
Re:Genetic Algorithms: Evolving Human Faces
by jobeirne on Monday April 20, 2009 @11:18AM
(#570828)
I apologize for the attitude, and it wasn't directed at you, but it's driving me crazy how prevalent the confusion is as to what a genetic algorithm actually is.
Re:Genetic Algorithms: Evolving Human Faces
by RiderOfGiraffes on Monday April 20, 2009 @10:50AM
(#570774)
This is some definition of "gotta" with which I was not previously acquainted. People will use technical terms in a manner that is not technically accurate. You can't stop them, it's part of the way language and communication works.
It's annoying, it's inaccurate, it's occasionally misleading, but it's inevitable.
Re:Genetic Algorithms: Evolving Human Faces
by ccc3 on Monday April 20, 2009 @12:17PM
(#570931)
I'm not sure you're right about that. I think of a genetic algorithm as an optimization algorithm that imitates a genetic reproductive process. This algorithm seems to be a rough approximation of binary fission instead of sexual reproduction. Still a genetic process, just a different one than is typically used.
Re:Genetic Algorithms: Evolving Human Faces
by sep332 on Monday April 20, 2009 @10:50AM
(#570777)
Yeah, this is basically just Newton's method of approximation, seeded with a random initial value. It will eventually converge on a local maximum defined by the facial recognition function.
People have gotta stop referring to population-based methods of stochastic search as "genetic algorithms".
Also, the title "Steady-state-ish (MU, LAMBDA) evolution strategies algorithm, and/or population-based stochastic search: Evolving Human Faces" is too long.
My issue with your titling "Genetic Algorithms" is that it is not simply a more convenient, abstract way of expressing what you did: it is in fact a contradiction of terms with the underlying technical details of what you did.
It's annoying, it's inaccurate, it's occasionally misleading, but it's inevitable.
@lbrandy: Awesome, if slightly mislabelled, work.