Re:Government obtains wide AP phone records in probe
by harold on Monday May 13, 2013 @08:48PM
(#5702410)
How do you feel about general whistleblowers like Peter Van Buren[1] and Gregory Hicks[2]? Neither have been prosecuted, but it's hard to deny they have been persecuted for their positions.
[1] http://www.motherjones.com/politics/2013/01/obama-whistleblo...
[2] http://www.cbsnews.com/8301-3460_162-57582929/official-we-kn...
Re:Government obtains wide AP phone records in probe
by tptacek on Monday May 13, 2013 @08:57PM
(#5702445)
I'm not clear on how Hicks claims to have been persecuted. Van Buren was fired after writing a tell-all book (which got him demoted to a work-from-home position) and maintaining a blog that linked to Wikileaks documents. I'm ambivalent about the prospect of being fired from a job for detracting from your government employer. On the one hand, you'd lose that same job at any private company where you did the same; on the other hand, in the public sector, detracting from your employer can be a public service. I guess I'd have to think about it on a case-by-case basis.
Re:Government obtains wide AP phone records in probe
by nym on Monday May 13, 2013 @08:23PM
(#5702345)
...But not Karl Rove
Re:Government obtains wide AP phone records in probe
by tptacek on Monday May 13, 2013 @08:38PM
(#5702383)
Karl Rove was not a federal government employee when Obama assumed office.
Re:Government obtains wide AP phone records in probe
by jmaygarden on Monday May 13, 2013 @11:21PM
(#5702861)
Don't you mean Richard Armitage? Read your link.
* Thomas Drake, an NSA employee who favored "ThinThread" instead of the later-adopted "Trailblazer" internet surveillance scheme, who then created a Hushmail account and fed classified documents to a reporter from it.
* Shamai Leibowitz, an FBI contractor/interpreter, who fed the contents of an cable intercepted from the Israeli embassy to a blogger because he felt it implicated Israel in an attack on Iran.
* Stephen Jin-Woo Kim, a career civil servant at State who worked on counterproliferation and North Korea and fed classified documents about North Korea to Fox News, and then lied to the FBI about having any contact with journalists.
* Bradley Manning
* Jeffrey Sterling, who was fired from the CIA, lodged a series of employment law disputes with the CIA, attempted to write a memoir about his time at CIA, and then fed classified details about Iranian counterproliferation to a reporter which put a human intelligence resource at risk.
* John Kiriakou, a CIA counterterrorism official who worked in Pakistan, who outed two covert operatives to a reporter (they had allegedly been involved in the Bush-era interrogation program).
Of this list, Kiriakou and Drake are sympathetic to me, but every single case here seems like a valid prosecution; when you take a role that requires you to handle the most sensitive data the government handles, you cannot share it with the press expecting not to end up arguing your side of the story in a court of law. You certainly can't out covert operatives, or feed foreign intercepts you translate to bloggers!