News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Zuckerberg’s Lobby Is Collapsing Outside Of DC by rayiner on Monday May 13, 2013 @01:16PM (#5699943)
> You don't think he's learned a few lessons in the past 10 years that gives him some insight that's useful?

Insight into running a big organization? Sure. Insight into global politics? Not really.

> Who gives a fuck if it drives down wages or puts more competition in the workforce. It's that versus a more open world for everyone.

My dad was an immigrant too, and I got my citizenship about 8 years after moving here (at which point I had been living in the U.S. for most of my life). I don't give a damn about a "more open world for everyone." The purpose of a country is to maximize the prosperity of its citizens. Sometimes that's furthered by making things more open, and sometimes it isn't, but the key consideration should be the people who are already part of the body politic.

That's the only morally justifiable way of running a democracy. The people did not give up some of their freedom in order to institute government just so that government could sell out their interests in favor of the interests of other people. Those people have governments to watch out for their interests--they don't need ours to do so. Certainly, they don't want their governments watching out for our interests at the expense of theirs.

Re:Why Zuckerberg’s Lobby Is Collapsing Outside Of DC by harryh on Monday May 13, 2013 @02:07PM (#5700337)
Can't a group of citizens can have interests beyond their personal prosperity?
Re:Why Zuckerberg’s Lobby Is Collapsing Outside Of DC by rayiner on Monday May 13, 2013 @02:20PM (#5700427)
Sure, and if that was the expressed view of the majority of the people, that's certainly the path government should follow.

The way I look at it is that some policies are intrinsically justifiable and some are not. If a policy is claimed to benefit the nation, it is intrinsically justifiable even if the people are not necessarily totally convinced of its utility (this is the prerogative of a government within a republican democratic system). If a policy is not claimed to benefit the nation, but to benefit other people, it must be justified on the basis of the fact that the people as a whole choose to be generous in that instance.