News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Instead of charging $X, why not charge $2X with prob 1/2 ... by nostrademons on Sunday April 19, 2009 @08:34PM (#569993)
I think you're interpreting people's irrationality in the wrong way. People are often irrationally risk averse: most people would much rather pay $X with probability 1 than $2X with probability 1/2 and $0 elsewhere. The reason lottery tickets sell is because utility functions are nonlinear. After buying a $1 lotto ticket, they're still poor; they don't miss the dollar. But if they win, suddenly they are rich, which is qualitatively different from being poor. Thus, the calculation is a small but nonzero chance of being rich, vs. the certainty of being poor. Most people don't do the math to figure out just how small.

There's a reason why people indulge "If I won the lottery..." fantasies.

Re:Instead of charging $X, why not charge $2X with prob 1/2 ... by nsrivast on Sunday April 19, 2009 @09:46PM (#570044)
Actually people are thought to be risk seeking when it comes to losses instead of gains.

http://www.jstor.org/pss/1914185

Unlike most people in this discussion, I like the idea and think it might work under certain circumstances (probably goods with low prices and high price inelasticity).

Re:Instead of charging $X, why not charge $2X with prob 1/2 ... by dfranke on Sunday April 19, 2009 @11:18PM (#570130)
Utility functions are nonlinear with decreasing slope. When you don't have enough money to buy everything you want, you buy the most important things first. A 50% chance of gaining 2x dollars is a worse deal than a 100% chance of gaining x dollars, with the difference in utility becoming more significant percentage-wise for larger x.

This rant used to conclude with "therefore, buying lottery tickets is irrational; period", but someone on Less Wrong recently brought up a valid exception: it can be rational if you're currently deeply in debt. Utility functions are actually sigma-shaped: they flatten as you get more deeply negative as well. Being two trillion in debt isn't very much worse than being one trillion in debt. So when you're in debt, your utility function can get steeper before it gets shallower.

Re:Instead of charging $X, why not charge $2X with prob 1/2 ... by nostrademons on Monday April 20, 2009 @12:23AM (#570202)
I think it's a lot more complicated than the diminishing-marginal-returns model taught in econ courses. For example, there's a pretty sharp discontinuity at "can move to a better neighborhood". There's another one at "can afford a vacation home", and another one at "can send kids to college". And then there's a big one at "never has to work again." When an event bumps you from one category into the next one up, it can often be rational to take a small chance at that rather unlikely event than to worry about a few dollars that don't make a material difference in your lifestyle anyway.

Actually, this is a big problem with conventional economics: it assumes that all variables are conventional. So income taxes don't affect people's willingness to work nearly as much as theory predicts, because their choice is usually between "Have a job" and "Don't have a job" and not "Do $30K of work per year" and "Do $40k of work per year". Unemployment exists because a business can't just drop wages to the equilibrium level, but rather workers make the choice between "I'm being paid fairly" and "I'm not being paid fairly" and act appropriately. Market niches are not instantly filled because entrepreneurship often has a binary outcome of "Get rich" and "Fail", and not a continuous distribution of outcomes.

Re:Instead of charging $X, why not charge $2X with prob 1/2 ... by nostrademons on Monday April 20, 2009 @11:41AM (#570863)
"all variables are conventional"

s/conventional/continuous/. I can't type at night.

Re:Instead of charging $X, why not charge $2X with prob 1/2 ... by amichail on Sunday April 19, 2009 @09:51PM (#570049)
If they don't like this scheme, you could allow them to pay $X with prob 1.

More generally, you could let them specify the pay probability p or price $Y >= $X. Given p, have them pay $X/p. Given $Y, make them pay with probability $X/$Y.

Re:Instead of charging $X, why not charge $2X with prob 1/2 ... by azbob on Sunday April 19, 2009 @10:04PM (#570058)
Actually, people play the lottery because they can't do math.
Re:Instead of charging $X, why not charge $2X with prob 1/2 ... by anigbrowl on Sunday April 19, 2009 @11:11PM (#570125)
I'm not so sure about that. In California (and in several other places I've lived) the odds of winning are written out on the back of the ticket. Sure, a lot of people believe in not-systems like studying past numbers or drawing numbers from their dreams or casting spells; but deep down I think most people understand 'odds of winning = 1 in 57 million'.

Lottery addicts certainly can't do math since they waste a lot of money on tickets. But a good many other people just buy one a week or just occasionally, eg when there's a particularly large jackpot on offer. This isn't so irrational; a regular player will make a few bucks back over the year on small prizes, and the risk/reward ratio improves for a big jackpot even though the odds don't.

It's worth recalling that while the odds on any individual ticket are awful, enough people are playing that people do win big prizes on a semi-regular basis. For small-spend players who can afford it, and may think of it as semi-charitable given the uses to which lottery profits are put, is it really any more irrational than certain kinds of insurance?

Re:Instead of charging $X, why not charge $2X with prob 1/2 ... by jamesbritt on Monday April 20, 2009 @12:08AM (#570188)
Same goes for renting movies. And it's worse, because there's about zero chance of winning money renting a movie. :)

Some people get a kick out of the whole buy a ticket, wait for the numbers, get excited dreaming thing.

For some folks, it's entertainment.

Re:Instead of charging $X, why not charge $2X with prob 1/2 ... by cubicle67 on Sunday April 19, 2009 @10:07PM (#570061)
Q: How do you increase your odds of winning Lotto by 0.0000001%?

A: Buy a ticket