News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Philip Greenspun Reviews “Lean In” by jackowayed on Monday May 13, 2013 @04:03AM (#5697649)
The reason that people are berated for suggesting inherent differences is that there's so much more to the story. Almost nothing derives purely from genes; it's a complex interaction of genes, epigenetics (environmental and hereditary factors other than genes that control which genes are active), and socialization.

Males and females are treated extremely differently from birth. Literally, in the very first day. Thus, it is nearly impossible to actually prove scientifically that a significant difference comes from genetic and biological factors. The socialization is a confounding factor that's impossible to separate out unless you're willing to do a study where you raise kids in isolation from society so you can treat them identically.

And even "inherent" differences are often easily overcome with social solutions. There's research to suggest that the difference in spatial reasoning is societal.[1] Furthermore, I believe I saw a study suggesting that even in our society, if you put everyone through a proper course teaching them spatial reasoning, the women catch up to the men. So society can choose to eliminate "inherent" differences by devoting a few resources to something that helps one group catch up to the other.

Furthermore, it ultimately doesn't matter that much. Western society has decided that we want equality between men and women. If that's not happening, then we've committed ourselves to make it happen. There are currently differences between men and women, largely from socialization. Since our society was largely built by men, it unsurprisingly is oriented toward having successful men in it. That doesn't mean we throw up our hands and say, "well, this is how our society is structured, and our society socializes men to win in that structure. I guess equality is inherently impossible." No. We find ways to reduce gender socialization (see: radical schools in Sweden). We find ways to restructure society so that there are fewer barriers to some groups' success.

1: http://lesswrong.com/lw/7fk/gender_differences_in_spatial_re...

Re:Philip Greenspun Reviews “Lean In” by temphn on Monday May 13, 2013 @05:16AM (#5697825)
You don't link to actual molecular genetic research on behavior and sex differences. I will. Let's do two quick examples.

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/02/15/science/studying-recent-hu...

  Gaining a deep insight into human evolution, researchers 
  have identified a mutation in a critical human gene as the 
  source of several distinctive traits that make East Asians 
  different from other races.

  The traits — thicker hair shafts, more sweat glands, 
  characteristically identified teeth and smaller breasts — 
  are the result of a gene mutation that occurred about 
  35,000 years ago, the researchers have concluded.
One pleiotropic mutation actually causes smaller breasts, among other things. For added visual impact, take a look at the EDAR transgenic mouse:

http://mathildasanthropologyblog.files.wordpress.com/2008/10...

Wow! Across species, you can actually see that a single variant makes the mouse hair look East Asian. It's so crazily reductionist, it looks like what a troglodyte like Strom Thurmond might sketch if you had him draw an "Asian-looking mouse". Here's another great one, Fruitless:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fruitless_(gene)#Function

  Although many genes are known to be involved in male 
  courtship behavior, the fruitless gene has been considered 
  noteworthy because it exhibits sex-specific alternative 
  splicing. When females produce the male-spliced gene 
  product, they behave as males. Males that do not produce 
  the male-specific product do not court females and are 
  infertile.[1] ... The fruitless gene locus also controls 
  the expression of hundreds of other genes,[6] any subset of 
  which may actually regulate behavior.
We don't yet know the human analog of Fruitless, the master regulator of sex differences. But if it exists, it's a good bet that it's on the Y or X chromosomes.

Point: it's not all super-complex gene-environment interactionism that we'll never understand[1]. Indeed, as Fruitless or the EDAR story show, the genetic origins of complex gender differences and/or behavioral traits can be almost cartoonishly reductionist, attributable to a single master upstream regulator!

So: do you really want to bet it all on black, bet that genetics researchers aren't going to find governing loci for human gender differences and/or sexual orientation, bet that it's 100% social construction? Because if you know anything about where genomics is going, that is a bet you are going to lose.

[1] PS: I love it when people bring up epistasis, for god's sake, as a sort of catch-all neo-Lamarckianism, reached for like a drowning sailor flailing for a life preserver. Methylome much? Didn't think so.

EDIT: You know what? Let's actually go line by line on this thing.

  Males and females are treated extremely differently from 
  birth. Literally, in the very first day. Thus, it is nearly 
  impossible to actually prove scientifically that a 
  significant difference comes from genetic and biological 
  factors. 
Science: doing the impossible since ten years ago. Behold, gene expression analysis of innate male/female neurological differences before birth, known since 2003 (and well before):

http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2003/10/031022062408.ht...

  Using two genetic testing methods, they compared the 
  production of genes in male and female brains in embryonic 
  mice — long before the animals developed sex organs.

  To their surprise, the researchers found 54 genes produced 
  in different amounts in male and female mouse brains, prior 
  to hormonal influence. Eighteen of the genes were produced 
  at higher levels in the male brains; 36 were produced at 
  higher levels in the female brains.

  “We didn’t expect to find genetic differences between the  
  sexes’ brains,” Vilain said. “But we discovered that the 
  male and female brains differed in many measurable ways, 
  including anatomy and function.”
How about this little flail-for-a-life-preserver:

  There's research to suggest that the difference in spatial 
  reasoning is societal.
Which in turn links to this paper: http://www.pnas.org/content/early/2011/08/19/1015182108.full...

This is almost a caricature of academia. To come to the conclusion that gender differences in spatial rotation ability are "culturally influenced"...they analyze two tribes in Northeast India on a "spatial puzzle" that has never been administered to anyone before (Figure 1). And in Table 1 the mean puzzle solving time for men in the "matrilineal" society is still actually lower than that for females, even though the medians point the other way.

Forget about the crimes against psychometry that such a test perpetrates. It goes without saying that they did not compute test-retest reliabilities or do a proper battery of spatial tests, let alone estimate IRT parameters for their single idiosyncratic "spatial" item. And this innocence of all aspects of item-response theory is confirmed by their supplementary information (http://goo.gl/ltysD).

The more fundamental point is the lack of thinking. Not only does this study cut against the grain of literally hundreds of other datasets, it is intentionally designed to not be reproducible. Among other things, why else would one use such an obscure population? And why not use the standard Shepard/Metzler test, in which one is actually mentally rotating two objects and seeing if they correspond? One can programmatically vary the rotation parameter to increase the difficulty, and Shepard famously even observed that reaction time varies linearly with rotation angle (http://plato.stanford.edu/entries/mental-imagery/mental-rota...), as if people were actually rotating the objects slowly in their heads.

Anyway. You know what is reproducible? Let's consult this handy meta-analysis of 70 studies...

http://link.springer.com/article/10.1007%2Fs10648-012-9215-x

It shows a huge and reproducible spatial rotation ability difference between men and women. Don't believe me? Put up a web-based test with WebGL, pay participants, and reproduce the result for yourself. But something tells me that you may not really be interested in such studies. Instead:

  Furthermore, it ultimately doesn't matter that much. 
  Western society has decided that we want equality between 
  men and women. If that's not happening, then we've 
  committed ourselves to make it happen. 
Right. Comrade, here is where I bid you adieu. If men and women have fundamental neurological differences, which all the evidence indicates that they do, attempting to "close the gap" in mathematically & spatially challenging software engineering is a Sisyphean task. It is as futile as encouraging women to make it to the NBA and out-dunk the very best men. While there will be a Lisa Leslie or Cheryl Miller, there won't be very many of them, and that won't be the fault of men.

Because there can be no obligation to do that which cannot be done.

Re:Philip Greenspun Reviews “Lean In” by polymatter on Monday May 13, 2013 @07:53AM (#5698166)
I try to keep an open mind, but I am finding it difficult to get past your tone. I find people as confident and dismissive as you appear to be, are the crackpots who are not worth my time. You don't have anything in your HN profile either. But you also went to the trouble to provide references, so I am confused and want to learn more.

Are you seriously suggesting its a Sisyphean task to teach women maths or business on the basis that - on average - these have historically been male dominated careers? If not, can you please explain further. Are you aware that 50 years ago women faced massive discrimination and that this may still be having a lag effect today? Have you heard of stereotype threat enough to convince someone who believes in it?

You are being condescending and rude and seem to expect your audience to share your conviction in a fringe view of genetic determinism. Nobody is disputing men and women are genetically different. That this change extends to neurological changes should hardly be surprising. Different machinery require different control structures. The scientific debate is on exactly how significant these differences are compared to other factors that have significant influence including the culture. I don't think the parent was even suggesting it was 100% cultural effect either. Whereas you seem to suggest its 100% genetic, which would preclude the possibility of any woman having better spatial abilities than any man - which I hope sounds as ridiculous to you as it does me.

Re:Philip Greenspun Reviews “Lean In” by temphn on Monday May 13, 2013 @03:34PM (#5700908)

  Have you heard of stereotype threat enough to convince 
  someone who believes in it?
Well, stereotype threat has actually been debunked. I encourage you to read this full pdf, including Steele and Aronson's response and Sackett/Hardison/Cullen's reply:

http://www.asc.upenn.edu/usr/ogandy/C45405%20resources/Sacke...

  I find people as confident and dismissive
This is a matter of perception. From my vantage point, people who don't know much about genetics, neuroscience, biochemistry and the like are extraordinarily confident in dismissing the influence of hard scientific evidence in favor of the wishful thinking and hand-waving of much less rigorous sociological disciplines.

  I don't think the parent was even suggesting it was 100%  
  cultural effect either. 
See above: jackowayed himself notes that people with an alternative opinion are "berated". Only on the internet can the facts about genetics even be stated without character assassination. And then, and only then, the backpedal starts from a 100% cultural to a "50/50" position.

Who knows what the split is? How can we know? Gene-culture environment interaction is so complex. And what about _epistasis_.

But "we don't know" is not the position that Sandberg takes. And of course, if the position is actually not 100/0 then these gaps can never be fully closed [even if this were desirable], and this resilient inequality is not the fault of men but of Nature itself. Now, correct me if I'm wrong, but I don't think "the gap can never be closed" is a position you would subscribe to (let alone jackowayed or Sandberg herself). So yeah, I think it's fair to characterize the conventional wisdom as a 100% social constructionist position, which executes a tactical rhetorical fallback when confronted with overwhelming fact...changing not one iota in its policy prescriptions, which are still in the main comprised of struggle sessions at places like Facebook HQ.

  Whereas you seem to suggest its 100% genetic, which would 
  preclude the possibility of any woman having better spatial 
  abilities than any man
You know, there's something about this topic which makes people unable to reason statistically. Obviously there are tall women and short men. Obviously there are Emmy Noethers. That's just not where the averages or medians are. I mentioned Lisa Leslie and Cheryl Miller; y'all really think people who know what item-response theory is aren't intimately familiar with the concept of overlapping Gaussians...maybe even more so than people who blanche at the very thought of Bell Curves?

But overlap isn't equality.

Re:Philip Greenspun Reviews “Lean In” by edwinkite on Monday May 13, 2013 @10:46PM (#5702784)
My basic gripe with Bell-curve arguments against female genius is that at the high end, in the exponential tail, fine-tuning is needed to explain why a non-negligible fraction of professors at MIT (say) are women. Even a small difference in variance would lead to overwhelming male dominance.

On the other hand, if there were no difference in the distribution of intelligence, but cultural factors held women back, then the current "one-tenth to one-third" fraction of women in jobs needing high intelligence is naturally explained.

A recent PNAS paper showed that International Mathematics Olympiad teams from countries with high gender equality contain more women. http://www.pnas.org/content/106/22/8801.abstract IMO team members are one-in-a-hundred-thousand people - deep into the exponential tail of any Bell curve.

A study in 1999 showed 70% of psychology professors hiring Robert, and 45% hiring Ruth, on the basis of an identical CV. The waters of geek sexism run deep.

Cordelia Fine wrote a good book on the evidence. PDF: http://hagocrat.files.wordpress.com/2012/06/delusions-of-gen...

It's totally anecdotal, but the young people in the canteen at JPL are about 50/50.

Notice also the political fine-tuning of the variance argument: it doesn't dare suggest that mean female intelligence is lower (because we'd all reject that). God of the gaps, anyone?

Getting this right matters. If you must hire very good people, and you have the wrong model of how very good people are distributed among the population, you will fail.

Re:Philip Greenspun Reviews “Lean In” by temphn on Tuesday May 14, 2013 @03:44AM (#5703466)

  My basic gripe with Bell-curve arguments against female   
  genius is that at the high end, in the exponential tail, 
  fine-tuning is needed
Well, actually no fine-tuning is needed. The Central Limit Theorem is most valid for a sum process in the middle of the distribution. It converges most slowly in the tails [1,2]; indeed, if your goal is to model the tails you really are dealing with a max-phenomenon rather than a mean-phenomenon.

In this case, the underlying sum process could be a bunch of small alleles of roughly equivalent size, each contributing to high IQ (viz. a QTL model for a multifactorial trait [3]). In that case, if you cared about the tails rather than the body, the discrete chunkiness of the underlying binomial distribution becomes more crucial.

Put another way: Bell Curve arguments (aka "statistical genetics") are at the lowest level based on discrete alleles, not perfect Gaussians. Now, those in the field would love to get better models of the genetics of highly intelligent people -- but to study that kind of thing you need to move to China and work at BGI. Remember, thoughtcriminals who propose genetic explanations for behavioral phenomena are "berated" in the US [See jackowayed's wonderful admission against interest up thread].

  International Mathematics Olympiad.. Notice also the 
  political fine-tuning of the variance argument: it doesn't 
  dare suggest that mean female intelligence is lower 
  (because we'd all reject that). God of the gaps, anyone?
While we're talking about fine-tuning, why do you cherry-pick a few stats without acknowledging that the history of science is male? Do the thousands of male names (Newton, Maxwell, Einstein, Gauss, Euler) that have inscribed their name into history count as a datapoint here? Do the Fields Medals? The Nobel Prizes in Physics? The faculty of math and science departments around the world? The gender of the inventors of the locomotive, the aeroplane, and the automobile? The names of those men who built steam engines and search engines?

I know why. All the conquests and murders in history are counted against men; but is a little odd that every male invention is counted in the demerits column too! I think the idea is that said ancient men ostensibly discriminated against women, shoving them out of the way before they could figure out the value of pi. Without said invidious discrimination women - biologically, neurologically, hormonally, genetically different women - would have been tearing it up on the math tip at the same rate. Just as they have been dunking from the free throw line ever since we started the WNBA.

Bottom line: you can't have it both ways. If achievement in science and engineering is to be a signal, if you are to cite any stats related to IMOs and whatnot, you need to take on board the enormous imbalance in the favor of men on historical measures of sci/eng aptitude and achievement. All due respect to Noether, Daubechies, and Curie -- but the prior probabilities of achievement are not equal.

  If you must hire very good people, and you have the wrong   
  model of how very good people are distributed among the 
  population, you will fail.
That's right. Your statement is: if you have the wrong model, you will fail.

The logically equivalent contrapositive is: if you succeed, you didn't have the wrong model.

So given that Google, Facebook, Twitter, Youtube succeeded with highly male software engineering staffs, logically they did not have the wrong model of how very good people are distributed among the population.

[1] http://math.stackexchange.com/questions/314659/central-limit...

[2] http://www.cs.toronto.edu/~yuvalf/CLT.pdf (see page 2)

[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantitative_trait_locus#Multif...

Re:Philip Greenspun Reviews “Lean In” by wnight on Tuesday May 14, 2013 @02:09AM (#5703210)
> I find people as confident and dismissive as you [...]

But what do you find about the cites? The evidence, and the arguments?

> [...] your conviction in a fringe view of genetic determinism.

Oh, that's easy then. It's easy to disprove perpetual motion crackpots, or infinite compression weirdos, the homeopathic fringe, etc. So trot out a few choice articles.

> You are being condescending and rude [...]

Okay, once is enough - now you're just playing for sympathy. If you don't like someone's tone, don't answer it.

Re:Philip Greenspun Reviews “Lean In” by quadhome on Monday May 13, 2013 @08:03AM (#5698194)
Because there can be no obligation to do that which cannot be done.

And because it "cannot be done," we are to close the doors on anyone who cares to try?

Re:Philip Greenspun Reviews “Lean In” by wnight on Monday May 13, 2013 @09:38PM (#5702579)
If they're trying on their own dollar, no.

But there's a difference too in how they do it. I don't think we should try to make people equal, but to make people equally represented by society.