But that aside: I didn't ask the question because I wanted to condem Occupy Oakland.
I asked because the thread started with the suppression of the assiduously nonviolent (or "nonviolent") Zucotti Park protests.
But if our friends in Oakland are reporting those protests accurately, there was little chance of the Oakland protests not meeting a violent police response; Occupy Oakland was breaking windows, throwing bricks, destroying ATMs, and assaulting residents.
Occupations across the country and the world met similar evictions through the use of force, although the use of tear gas specifically has been rare in the US.
If there was any qualitative difference in the police response, I think it has more to do with the character of OPD than the character of OO. The same thing happened at the port of oakland occupation in 2003 (where there was zero property destruction), which was equally brutal: https://www.commondreams.org/headlines03/0407-07.htm
What occupiers have to deal with isn't "dogs and firehoses," but an extremely well equipped paramilitary force.
Watch this video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QngE6kKk8Lg
Now imagine how difficult it is to wake up every morning and throw yourself into that all over again, particularly once you've been dispersed and have lost the tactical advantage of being garrisoned together in one space. The most hardcore people I know became afraid to go back into that, as were veterans of war.
It is inevitable that the moment ruptured (as it was for the globalization, biotech, and war moments before this). However, I think this Zizek speech at OWS captures the value of that inevitability really well:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=eu9BWlcRwPQ