Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement
by philwelch on Sunday May 12, 2013 @04:45PM
(#5695759)
The reason retirement doesn't work the same way as a bicycle shop is because the incentives can get badly misaligned. With a bicycle shop, the better you are at fixing bicycles, the more money you make, at least to a good-enough order of approximation. Taking your customer's money just isn't possible unless you give them back a working bicycle. But retirement--especially "defined contribution" retirement--has a much weaker requirement. You give money to a mutual fund, and then who knows what'll happen? The mutual fund takes their fee off the top regardless. You let the company that's servicing your 401k or IRA pick funds for you and they'll just pick some plausible combination of their own funds. At least with pensions they have to maximize their return to have any hope of profiting.
Probably the closest analogy to retirement is auto repair and maintenance. You go in for an oil change and you get back a hundred-something-point inspection where they want to do a thousand dollars worth of work on your car. If you don't know anything about cars, there's no way to tell whether they're ripping you off. With retirement it's even worse, because you started off by giving them the money without any guarantee of how much money makes its way back to you. And the only solution is to actually know something about investing, which was pretty much what you were paying these companies for in the first place.
Probably the closest analogy to retirement is auto repair and maintenance. You go in for an oil change and you get back a hundred-something-point inspection where they want to do a thousand dollars worth of work on your car. If you don't know anything about cars, there's no way to tell whether they're ripping you off. With retirement it's even worse, because you started off by giving them the money without any guarantee of how much money makes its way back to you. And the only solution is to actually know something about investing, which was pretty much what you were paying these companies for in the first place.