News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement by ChuckMcM on Sunday May 12, 2013 @02:15PM (#5695218)
I think the Money Moustache guy has a much better take on this than someone trying to figure out the complexities of finance.

Yes there is a limit to how much you can put into a retirement account that isn't taxed by the government, but there is no limit on how much of your income you can save, caveat you need some of it to live on.

And while saving and investing can get as complicated as you want it can also be greatly simplified with funds investing.

Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement by scarmig on Sunday May 12, 2013 @03:25PM (#5695491)
MMM gets so much right it's not even funny. I question some aspects of his plan--my time discount is higher than his, so I think it makes more sense to save up less and transition to part time labor more quickly, which is what he did de facto anyway except with a couple extra years of unnecessary shitty corporate work.

The guy in this article talks about how to safely retire you must have saved up eleven times your annual income. Which is wrong: the key value is about thirty times your annual consumption if you want to transition to full time retirement (with no market labor involved). And if you add in maybe $10k of market labor a year, that amount of required savings drops very sharply. $20k, and hell, you're probably able to increase your nest egg if you watch your consumption at all.

Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement by saryant on Sunday May 12, 2013 @03:04PM (#5695422)
I'm a big fan of the "lazy portfolio." Three funds, nothing more: Vanguard total domestic stock, total international stock and total bond market. Buy and hold forever (rebalancing towards more conservative assets as you near retirement).
Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement by philwelch on Sunday May 12, 2013 @04:28PM (#5695705)
Vanguard even has target funds that do exactly this, rebalancing included.
Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement by saryant on Sunday May 12, 2013 @05:17PM (#5695874)
True, and I'm in one of those right now. Once you have enough in your account however you're better off handling the rebalancing yourself and using Vanguard's Admiral shares which have lower expense ratios.
Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement by hexis on Sunday May 12, 2013 @05:03PM (#5695825)
What are the names of those funds?
Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement by gergles on Sunday May 12, 2013 @05:27PM (#5695925)
VTSMX, VGTSX, VBMFX - with corresponding Admiral versions if you have enough money, which are the same funds with even lower expense ratios.

Edit: You wanted the rebalancing funds (those are the component funds.) The rebalancing funds are called "LifeStrategy" - see VASGX for an example.

Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement by saryant on Sunday May 12, 2013 @06:52PM (#5696209)
There's also the "Target Retirement" family of funds. I'm currently in the 2050 fund, VFIFX.
Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement by hexis on Monday May 13, 2013 @03:15PM (#5700776)
Thank you.
Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement by nilkn on Sunday May 12, 2013 @08:23PM (#5696515)
I think the limit on IRA and 401(k) contributions was just a passing comment in the article, not the main point.

The main question he seems to be asking is how the average American is expected to effectively plan for retirement when companies no longer feel they can manage pension funds with professional investors.

The real answer to this, IMHO, is that companies definitely could provide pension plans. Some do (Chevron comes to mind). They just don't want to because it's cheaper to just give your employees a 401(k) and only put company money into it if your employees contribute.

Companies didn't transition to 401(k)s because pensions were impossible to pull off. They transitioned to 401(k)s because they realized they could still sell their benefit plan as offering a "retirement plan" to their employees, but the majority of their employees wouldn't even utilize the matching, thereby saving them tons of cash.

Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement by patio11 on Monday May 13, 2013 @02:02AM (#5697393)
That's the Snidely Whiplash version. Some other reasons:

+ The character of work and the workforce changed markedly in America over the years, from an economy where a man employed by BigCo could reasonably be assumed to work for BigCo until the day he died, to an economy where men and women work, labor force participation is often interrupted, and stints exceeding 3 to 5 years at a company are unusual enough to be remarked upon, to say nothing of 40+ years.

+ Defined-benefits pensions come bundled with a few other expectations, such as lifetime employment and tenure, which are sort of on the outs at US companies.

+ Defined-benefits pensions are highly correlated to workplaces which are toxic to work in, because you'll frequently find yourself surrounded by clockpunching deadwood whose sole goal in working is not doing anything to upset their chances of making pension. If you've worked in government or a union shop, you know what I mean. If you haven't, try doing software development for a week in a union shop, then evaluate whether receiving a pension is sufficient to have yourself sentenced to doing that for 40 years.

Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement by greenlander on Sunday May 12, 2013 @09:00PM (#5696632)
Agreed. I only found the Money Moustache guy a few weeks ago, but somehow I was born with the same mentality of him.

I always saved the majority of my income. Last year I retired from my corporate job at the age of 40. It really is possible to do.

Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement by ChuckMcM on Monday May 13, 2013 @01:00PM (#5699829)
As long as you don't have kids :-) Or perhaps you're counting on them to pay for their own education. But yes, if you save your money and budget well, retirement is simply an 'if condition' rather than a 'when.'

That said, he doesn't cover variable costs as much as he should (rent changes, taxes, sudden medical issue) this is something that fixed income folks have lived with so there is a lot of stuff out there for managing those events as well.