Re:An Incomprehensible Retirement
by PaulHoule on Sunday May 12, 2013 @01:58PM
(#5695144)
Sometimes I wonder if the way out of the recession is to declare 401K and IRA failed policies and just let people have the money and spend it now to get the economy moving.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
People with 401Ks or IRAs are people who have taken active measures to improve their own financial security decades from now in exchange for lower in-pocket funds at this moment.
If retirement accounts were ended tomorrow and all that money was deposited directly into their checking accounts, they wouldn't go out and spend it on televisions and new rims. They would invest it, probably into the same low-risk ETFs or mutual funds that were being held in the retirement accounts.
The only difference would be a change in when the money is taxed.
And then what will those people fund their retirements with?
The money that is moved from a 401k to the market, so they can spend and save it as they wish. You don't have to spend all the money you make that doesn't end up in a 401k; in fact, if you do, you're doing it wrong.
The only people whose retirement would be adversely affected are mutual fund managers.
How about everyone who has to suddenly start paying taxes on the money they're saving for retirement? 401k is just a tax shield. You want to raise taxes to stimulate the economy??