It is even more complicated than that.
What about some company that uses a Chinese factory that is known to employ workers under 18?
Evil[1] right?
Well sure, unless you dig in to the numbers and find out that the company mandates no under age workers in their portion of the factory.
[1] See discussion below, definitions of evil vary!
Hell, in the US, there isn't even a minimum age limit for farm labor[1], and the minimum age for non-farm labor is 14, with anybody over 16 being allowed to work unlimited/full-time hours[2].
[1]http://www.dol.gov/dol/topic/youthlabor/agriculturalemployme... [2]http://www.dol.gov/dol/topic/youthlabor/agerequirements.htm
A lot of people disagree with it and want to spend their money accordingly.
Many of these issues are subjective, I fully agree that it often isn't black and white.
Of course, that's a distraction. I worked for the government when I was twelve, but I only worked an hour or two a week.
Anything that centralizes this kind of information even if it doesn't completely parse out the good/bad would be nice
I believe you're referring to: http://tosdr.org/
That said, it'd be an interesting project, even if the metrics would be a complete nightmare; am I more pro- environmental regulation than I am pro- gun control? How do you rate Company X lobbying for Bill Y on a scale of Things I Don't Like?. I suppose you'd have to go down a machine learning path for individuals, maybe starting with presenting alternatives for whatever thing you're interested in spending money on, a la the plain English terms of service site that was set up a year or two ago (that I've lost the URL for[1]) and building a profile from there.
Realistically though, I think the whole exercise would just depress anyone who took it on.
[1]It was indeed http://tosdr.org/ - Thanks :) re-bookmarked!