News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: Why would anyone POST anything in AJAX? by jon_dahl on Saturday April 18, 2009 @06:35PM (#568831)
PUT is supposed to be idempotent? So an "increment" or "reverse" request should technically be a POST?

Or does the idempoten-cy apply only to the response from the server, and not the state of the data on the server?

Re:Ask HN: Why would anyone POST anything in AJAX? by cperciva on Saturday April 18, 2009 @09:28PM (#568974)
PUT is supposed to be idempotent? So an "increment" or "reverse" request should technically be a POST?

Absolutely. User-agents are allowed to retry PUTs transparently -- it's only for POSTs that they're supposed to put up a "are you sure you want to re-submit this form? Bad stuff might happen" dialog.

Re:Ask HN: Why would anyone POST anything in AJAX? by pmjordan on Saturday April 18, 2009 @06:39PM (#568834)
That's certainly my understanding of it. PUT has semantics of resource creation or updating, like writing a file: whatever you upload replaces what is already there, if anything. You can process the data of course, but the outcome should depend only on the request data itself, not state.