News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The human-powered helicopter challenge by HyprMusic on Friday May 10, 2013 @08:38AM (#5685832)
The helicopter requires pedalling with both hands and feet. Upper body strength is not something that goes hand-in-hand with cycling, due to the extra weight.
Re:The human-powered helicopter challenge by davidw on Friday May 10, 2013 @08:42AM (#5685849)
Well, they do seem to have picked cyclists as test pilots.

It may be, too, that the hand pedals are more of a distraction. It's something that has been tried with bicycles, and in general doesn't work out very well. Granted, in part this may be because you also have to steer a bike, whereas for a short effort like this, that's not so important. There's something to be said in any case for an otherwise rigid frame that you can hold onto with your hands, and really just sink all the leg power you can into it, kind of like standing up on a bicycle as you go uphill: you actually do pull on the bars.

Re:The human-powered helicopter challenge by maxerickson on Friday May 10, 2013 @08:58AM (#5685901)
They did a little bit of testing:

http://www.agrc.umd.edu/gamera/gamera2/gamera2-human-power.h...

Page also mentions that their pilots weigh less than 145 pounds. I bet it matters a lot and wonder where the pros you are citing come in.

Re:The human-powered helicopter challenge by davidw on Friday May 10, 2013 @09:08AM (#5685940)
Great link; it's interesting to see that indeed, they do get a lot more out of the hand cranks.

> I bet it matters a lot and wonder where the pros you are citing come in.

Where they come in is that a small climber has an excellent power to weight ratio. This guy weighs 48 kg, for instance: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jos%C3%A9_Rujano

Re:The human-powered helicopter challenge by stouset on Friday May 10, 2013 @03:30PM (#5688205)
Power to weight ratio varies over time as well. Smaller guys are great at climbing long distances, because they can maintain a higher power-to-weight ratio for an hour or longer. Bigger guys tend to be sprinters (Chris Hoy is 205lbs) because their peak power can be much, much higher and compensate for the extra weight. For a one-minute effort, I'd suspect that a somewhat heavier sprinter profile would be an advantage over a lightweight climber profile.

Even moreso because the weight of the craft will be a smaller percentage of their overall weight. A 150lb cyclist capable of outputting 10W/kg for a minute will have an effective 6.6W/kg on a 75lb craft. A 180lb cyclist capable of the same 10W/kg would have an effective 7.0W/kg on the same craft. And a 180lb cyclist capable of 11W/kg would manage an effective 7.7W/kg.

Re:The human-powered helicopter challenge by jeffasinger on Friday May 10, 2013 @11:51AM (#5686853)
The Pros tend to be pretty light. Guideline for weight of a cyclist is (Height in Inches) x2 = (Weight in Pounds).
Re:The human-powered helicopter challenge by Retric on Friday May 10, 2013 @10:57AM (#5686504)
This is a 90 second anaerobic sprint where cycling is an aerobic activity. Thus building up lactic acid in the upper body lets you extract more energy where the lungs can't support the extra load in aerobic cycling.
Re:The human-powered helicopter challenge by davidw on Friday May 10, 2013 @12:08PM (#5686971)
There are plenty of anaerobic efforts during most road races. Sure, it's primarily an aerobic activity, but you need to be able to 'go anaerobic' too.

Exhibit A would be the finish of the Fleche Wallone. This video (at about 8:00 ) shows it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DU-kNDQuiIo - just about 90 seconds.

Perhaps a more even distribution of lactic acid lets you generate more power overall... I don't know.

Re:The human-powered helicopter challenge by mistercow on Friday May 10, 2013 @10:48AM (#5686461)
> It's something that has been tried with bicycles, and in general doesn't work out very well. Granted, in part this may be because you also have to steer a bike, whereas for a short effort like this, that's not so important.

I would expect pedaling with your hands to be a huge stability problem on a bike, and once again, not so much of an issue with a helicopter.