Re:US Government Takes Down 3D Printed Gun Plans
by zero_intp on Friday May 10, 2013 @08:04AM
(#5685719)
>The fact that 3D printed guns control is infeasible doesn't mean that leaving them uncontrolled is a good idea.
Actually, that is exactly what it means. Infeasibility is a good place to stop, as it means that what you are doing is not reasonably possible.
Re:US Government Takes Down 3D Printed Gun Plans
by dllthomas on Friday May 10, 2013 @09:18AM
(#5685989)
I think there was some semantic mismatch here. The fact that something is infeasible means that it should not be the option selected. The fact that something is infeasable says nothing about whether it would be desirable granted feasibility. I am fairly confident you and the parent comment's author agree on both these points.
Now, how can we control it? I don't really know. I'm not for DRM. I'm not for controlling 3D printers, or 3D materials. And making an automated system so 3D printers don't print guns is infeasible, error-prone and a hassle. Maybe the best alternative is leaving those 3D printed guns uncontrolled, because any other option is ineffective.
The fact that 3D printed guns control is infeasible doesn't mean that leaving them uncontrolled is a good idea.