News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ask HN: How can a single person objecting get a post move... by ColinWright on Friday May 10, 2013 @06:48AM (#5685506)
I have no official standing, but I've been here a while, and I pay attention to community dynamics, so I may have an insight.

It doesn't take many flags from ordinary users to get an item off the front page. Flags carry a heavy penalty, and it seems that just three or four will take an item a long way down the rankings. If one person points out that they think an item is inappropriate, or isn't really of "deep interest" to the hacker culture/mentality, others will stop to wonder, and then they may also flag. Thus a single comment like that will often result in enough flags to take the item down quickly.

I've found a good predictor is the ratio of points to comments. The item you mention has 23 points but 42 comments. People are replying without upvoting, and that is a predictor of something that many will think is not really contributing value to the site as a whole. Correlation is not causation, etc, etc, but I've found it to be a good predictor of what I personally want to read.

So those are my thoughts - they're probably worth about as much as you paid for them.

Re:Ask HN: How can a single person objecting get a post move... by mike_tan on Friday May 10, 2013 @06:55AM (#5685524)
> It doesn't take many flags from ordinary users to get an item off the front page. Flags carry a heavy penalty, and it seems that just three or four will take an item a long way down the rankings. If one person points out that they think an item is inappropriate, or isn't really of "deep interest" to the hacker culture/mentality, others will stop to wonder, and then they may also flag. Thus a single comment like that will often result in enough flags to take the item down quickly.

So the one person, plus a couple of others is all it takes to surpress a story!

> I've found a good predictor is the ratio of points to comments. The item you mention has 23 points but 42 comments. People are replying without upvoting, and that is a predictor of something that many will think is not really contributing value to the site as a whole. Correlation is not causation, etc, etc, but I've found it to be a good predictor of what I personally want to read.

Or it could be a good talking point. On a subject people are interested in -- hence the votes to get it to the front page in the first place.

Re:Ask HN: How can a single person objecting get a post move... by mike_tan on Friday May 10, 2013 @07:02AM (#5685535)
Can I ask you a question, Colin. Do you think the subject of domains is against hacker culture, or anti-startup in any way?
Re:Ask HN: How can a single person objecting get a post move... by ColinWright on Friday May 10, 2013 @07:09AM (#5685562)
I can't comment on hacker culture, or what would be of interest to hackers, or what the HN "community" might regard as being of "deep interest." For me, the list was absolutely pointless, but I'm not looking for a domain.

And if I were starting a business again, I wouldn't care about three character *.io domains. And go look at the discussion - is there anything there of interest to hackers? Really?

Since you ask me personally, that entire thread feels like hackers shooting the breeze over coffee, and it has no substance. You may disagree, I'm sure there are many others who will, and I'm speaking for myself, from my perspective, with my background and interests. I personally wasn't interested in it.

But I didn't flag it - I am pretty parsimonious with flags, reserving them for what I feel is of serious negative value.

Re:Ask HN: How can a single person objecting get a post move... by mike_tan on Friday May 10, 2013 @07:29AM (#5685609)
> is there anything there of interest to hackers? Really?

codepen.io and card.io (who got acquired by Paypal) may disagree.

Or people using them for "playfully clever" things -- to use a term I've heard Richard Stallman use to define hackers.

Re:Ask HN: How can a single person objecting get a post move... by ColinWright on Friday May 10, 2013 @07:44AM (#5685665)
You're arguing with the wrong person in the wrong place. It got flagged, learn from it. Sometimes it's not what you say, but how you say it. If you think this is of interest then write a post explaining why, and include the data as part of the post, don't just submit raw data and expect everyone instantly to agree that it's interesting and of value.

I think I've pretty much said everything I have to say on the subject now. If you have a question or comment that isn't already answered in one of my other comments, fine, but otherwise I won't repeat myself further.

To quote Samuel Johnson:

    "Sir, I have found you an argument;
     but I am not obliged to find you an
     understanding."
Re:Ask HN: How can a single person objecting get a post move... by mike_tan on Friday May 10, 2013 @08:17AM (#5685760)
>don't just submit raw data and expect everyone instantly to agree that it's interesting and of value.

It was of value. People were taking action over the data.

You may not be looking to start a business, or do projects:

(To quote you from earlier) "And if I were starting a business again..."

But a lot of people on here are. And the very people who needed the data the most had it taken away from them.

Re:Ask HN: How can a single person objecting get a post move... by ColinWright on Friday May 10, 2013 @08:19AM (#5685766)