Now that's fascinating. Matching an IP address is a different thing than using information that a user has shared explicitly.
Even when you log out of Facebook, it keeps some cookies around.It could be more than just IP address.
Different browser, too. :P
On the other hand, I'm not sure how well separated I kept those, so it could have been cookies linking the accounts. (I did this way back in 2010, so my memory is fuzzy.)
The only thing I can think of is that it's matching IP addresses and concluding my two accounts are the same account.