News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Dear Apple, let's talk about photos by robomartin on Thursday May 09, 2013 @01:43AM (#5679000)
I am going to go a little further and suggest that Apple's entire iCloud + iTunes + backup + synchronization strategy/system/product/code is a disaster.

Why? Simple: You cannot trust it. You need to be able to trust such software. I'm sorry, but you just can't in this case.

I won't go into all of the details, links and examples here. Do a little searching and it should not be too hard to find hordes of people who have lost calendars, contacts, notes, photos and other valuable data thanks to Apple's wonderful software.

I have personally experienced loosing all of my contacts, appointments, calendar items and notes. Of course, being that this ain't my first rodeo I had backups of the backups. I always go into data storage situations with zero trust for what is being offered. It took some work to get the data back but I recovered.

That is not the point. The first three rules of any piece of software that users entrust with their data are:

  1- Thou shalt not loose user data
  2- Thou shalt not loose user data
  3- Thou shalt not loose user data
Notice that cool hippie user interfaces are never mentioned there. My data (and your data) is far more valuable than their cool icons and "beautiful" design. Far, far more valuable.

Go ahead, Google it. The stories are horrific. From people loosing contacts to students loosing semesters worth of notes. Auto-magically.

I even went to my local Apple store to consult with a "Genius" about this. The guy was clueless. And, in fact, right in front of my eyes, he proceeded to accidentally delete all of my calendar entries --something that should be darn-near impossible to do. Again, I had my backup at home so I didn't blow a fuse. But, please.

I explained that it was not reasonable to blow away someone's data if their email service provider changed. If you go from Google to Yahoo all the shit that was being synchronized with Google goes poof. Really? Why? I would love to hear from someone at Apple on this. Why it is even remotely reasonable to blow away all of my contacts, notes and calendar information?

If you close your email account and you are no-longer able to log-on it seems iOS will attempt to synchronize, fail and then blow away your data. My wife has had cases of constantly disappearing notes and appointments due to failed synchronization sessions.

The greater point is that you should not have to be a programmer or IT worker to have your personal data be safe on iOS. She is not a technical person and without my help she would have descended into data loss hell. Grandpa and Grandma have no hope.

Anyhow, now iCloud and all forms of automated synchronization are turned off on all of our devices. Manual backup is still the only way you can be sure your data will not be lost.

Re:Dear Apple, let's talk about photos by forrestthewoods on Thursday May 09, 2013 @03:26AM (#5679229)
Syncing all devices is fundamentally wrong and broken. Apple won't get it right until they drop the concept.

Try controlling what music from your vast library is currently on your tiny iphone. It's a god damned nightmare. Apple wants to "sync" which is just the wrong paradigm.

My phone is not synced with my itunes library. It's just contains a very small subset of it. If I were to draw a Venn diagram of "all the things" it would contain my iphone5, iphone4, ipad3, macbook, other icloud data, plus data on Apple's servers about what apps and TV shows I own but currently do not exist on any device in my possession. Each circle in the diagram has varying degrees of overlap with all the other circles. Not a single one is fully contained in any other. To proclaim that all of these devices are "fully synced" is just plain wrong.

Re:Dear Apple, let's talk about photos by Inufu on Thursday May 09, 2013 @05:51AM (#5679570)
This is where Google's Play Music works much better - your music is in the cloud by default, but you can "pin" specific albums to have them stored on the device.

If you play some song that's not on the device, it will be streamed and then cached for some time till space runs out.

Re:Dear Apple, let's talk about photos by th3james on Thursday May 09, 2013 @06:42AM (#5679691)
This is how iCloud works already, if all your music was bought from iTunes or if you're using iTunes match
Re:Dear Apple, let's talk about photos by lucian1900 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @04:50AM (#5679413)
This is terribly nit-picky, but reading "loose" so many times is making me crazy! It's "lose".
Re:Dear Apple, let's talk about photos by robomartin on Thursday May 09, 2013 @09:39AM (#5680353)
Crap. Agreed. Too late to edit. I don't know why I did that. Typing too fast. Also, I speak several languages.

English can be really inconsistent at times: "lose" and "loose" are pronounced exactly the same yet have different meanings. Yet "lost" is not pronounced "loost". Another one I hate: "read" can be pronounced "red" or "reed".

In sharp contrast to this Spanish is regular and consistent. I'll venture to say that even French can be more consistent than English.

That said, I am launching into learning Mandarin, which I understand can be tricky due to subtle pronoun inaction [see edit] and tone details.

EDIT: Damn, every time I type on my iPad there's something to regret. Here "pronoun inaction" was supposed to be "pronunciation". Time to turn off auto-no-help. Just try texting in multiple languages on your iPhone for some ROFL fun. Cute until you email or text a business contact and auto-no-help corrections make you sound like a total idiot.

Re:Dear Apple, let's talk about photos by tg3 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @10:36AM (#5680624)
Not sure if it's just my dialect of English (which is the "non-accent" accent) but I pronounce "lose" with a "z" sound (rhymes with booze) while I pronounce "loose" with an "s" sound (rhymes with noose or moose).
Re:Dear Apple, let's talk about photos by shpxnvz on Thursday May 09, 2013 @10:38AM (#5680638)
English can be really inconsistent at times: "lose" and "loose" are pronounced exactly the same yet have different meanings.

Not to be pedantic, but they are not pronounced the same in American English.

http://www.englishpage.net/showthread.php?10393-Pronunciatio...

Re:Dear Apple, let's talk about photos by robomartin on Thursday May 09, 2013 @12:18PM (#5681213)
True. Having learned a couple of other languages I can, however, place myself in the shoes of a non-native or less fluent speaker, and, to them, these words sound pretty much the same. It's like me with Chinese, it all sounds the same right now.

So, "lose" should really be spelled "looze", "looz" or some variant of that. Writing "lose" and pronouncing it \ˈlüz\ makes as much sense as writing "lost" and pronouncing it \ˈlüzt\.

Re:Dear Apple, let's talk about photos by wfunction on Sunday May 12, 2013 @02:55AM (#5693416)
> So, "lose" should really be spelled "looze", "looz" or some variant of that.

How should "have" be spelled?

Haav?

Re:Dear Apple, let's talk about photos by lucian1900 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @09:49AM (#5680403)
English is a terribly inconsistent language, yes. I suppose having both Germanic and Latin heritage, plus some other random bits does that to a language.

French is quite consistent as well, pleasantly so in comparison to English.

I had assumed only native English speakers misspel "lose", but you prove me wrong :) I don't think I ever got that particular word wrong, for some reason.

Re:Dear Apple, let's talk about photos by tigroferoce on Thursday May 09, 2013 @03:43AM (#5679271)
Agree. And let me point out another view on the "I cannot trust you" problem. iPhoto 11 allows me to publich photos on flickr. Fine. I could buy a pro account on flickr and publish all my photos there. But then who will ensure me that the publish-to-flickr option will stay there in the future?

I like iStuffs, and I buy them. But not being sure of how my personal data (and memories) will be handled in future, I'm more and more doubtful. Please Apple, go back to build things that just work fine as expected. And, by the way, I expect I can choose where backup my stuff without having to hack my computer.

Re:Dear Apple, let's talk about photos by robomartin on Thursday May 09, 2013 @09:50AM (#5680408)
Yeah, more of the same. I haven't explored every permutation. Once I decided the entire approach is fraught with data loss danger I moved on. There is no way to justify data loss, not for a company of the size and resources of Apple.

The mass deletion of user data should never be automatic or a single button function. This act should require the user to do something non-trivial and non-accidental. And, even if the data is deleted the system should save a copy and give you an option to restore it from the device with a few clicks.

Right now if you un-sync your contacts the only choice you seem to have is to delete them from the phone or keep using sync. Why not a "keep an independent copy on my phone" option. I would love to hear someone justify that concept. How are such decisions made?