I really think a big part of the problem in healthcare pricing is insurance company policies regarding networks and guaranteed volume. Your auto insurance doesn't demand you use a certain body shop, why should your health insurance?
Here's a practical example that recently came up for me. My wife is a nurse at a few clinics. At one clinic, she's got health insurance and that clinic provides IUDs via their hospital, which she wanted to get. At this clinic, the price billed to her insurance would be $4700.
At another clinic she works at, she could get the same IUD brand and procedure for $600.
When she asked her insurance about it, they said they would pay 100% of $4700 in-network but 60% of $600 out-of-network. Obviously, being selfish, she decided to let the company eat the $4100 they would otherwise save so that she would pay $0 instead of $240.
It may well be they paid less than $600 for a procedure that lists at $4100.
And of course the government numbers don't take this into account, so what they've published is pretty much worthless.
I don't disagree with you that insurance companies negotiate different discounts, though, which is what I was trying to get at in my post regarding pricing.
You know what is wild though? Federal employees aren't insured by medicare but instead the federal govt pays private insurers to insure them!
If the Feds went to single payer for its employees, things would change quickly.
How does this work? If a doctor prescribes a blood test, he's already said it's needed. Put yourself in a doctor's shoes for a minute. You told the patient he needs a blood test. Then he asks you whether it's actually needed.
How can you possibly say "Nah, just kidding. We don't need that one"?
If they have absolutely no idea what the possibilities are then they wouldn't be ordering tests anyway.
No they don't, except in very rare cases. Doctors order tests to make a diagnosis. The treatment follows from that.
>If they have absolutely no idea what the possibilities are then they wouldn't be ordering tests anyway.
I'm not sure a doctor would have "no idea what the possibilities are" unless you don't have any symptoms. If you don't have any symptoms, why are you at the doctor's office?
What I said didn't contract what you said. If test => diagnosis => treatment then test => treatment.
I don't believe that. Over the years I've had to fight to get tests that turned out to be important, and I'm suspicious of government studies showing "overtesting" right when the government is in the process of taking over health care.
You can certainly eliminate a lot of testing without affecting mortality rates significantly. But that's because in absolute terms a lot of extra people have to die before mortality rates are affected significantly.
etc etc.
That way patients can ask the doctors if the tests are actually needed.
You're right that emergency care becomes a lot more complicated.