News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by mikeash on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @07:03PM (#5677642)
People with serious diseases will outspend their voucher, and then many of them will die unnecessarily.

Give me a proposal that stops poor people from dying of treatable diseases (or at least gives the appearance of legitimately attempting to, as is the current state of things) while preserving market forces, and I'll change my mind. I've yet to see one, though. Not being allowed to refuse treatment screws up too much.

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by burntsushi on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @07:19PM (#5677726)
> Give me a proposal that stops poor people from dying of treatable diseases (or at least gives the appearance of legitimately attempting to, as is the current state of things) while preserving market forces, and I'll change my mind.

No such proposal exists. Any proposal that does requires a third party to intervene as either an angel to donate whatever resources are needed or as an agent enforcing policy that one group of people must provide services to another group of people regardless of means.

Both of the aforementioned scenarios do not exist within the realm of market forces because market forces cannot make guarantees.

People will always die because they don't have the resources to fix what ails them. We can only hope to lower the amount of resources to get treatment, and "market forces" are absolutely a legitimate solution to that.

But if you're stuck on "stop people from dying from preventable diseases" or "appearing to do so", then you've implicitly ruled out market forces completely.

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by mikeash on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @07:21PM (#5677740)
"But if you're stuck on "stop people from dying from preventable diseases" or "appearing to do so", then you've implicitly ruled out market forces completely."

We are in agreement. My point is that society is stuck on this (note that I have made no value judgment in these comments myself) and until and unless that changes, market forces are implicitly ruled out.

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by beagle3 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @03:19AM (#5679212)
Actually, the Israeli system does sort-of stop people from dying yet still lets market forces do some magic. It is single payer (gov) through taxes, every person chooses their HMO. The HMOs get paid per member (so they compete for the members) and they are also allowed to offer extra services to their members (which they also compete on). And finally - and I think this is also crucial - the government has a special fund for expensive life saving treatments that the HMOs tap into when needed - so they do not have an incentive to avoid those treatments.
Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by baddox on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @08:08PM (#5677976)
People with sufficiently serious diseases will die, period, even if they're the wealthiest people on Earth. I don't see how the inevitability of death caused by disease is a useful argument. If there was some disease that one person had, and that could be cured only by pooling the entire wealth of the Earth, should we forcefully take that wealth to cure that one person?
Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by wpietri on Thursday May 09, 2013 @04:00PM (#5682584)
That would be an interesting hypothetical if anybody sensible had ever suggested anything close to that.
Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by mseebach on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @07:30PM (#5677774)
> Give me a proposal that stops poor people from dying of treatable diseases while preserving market forces, and I'll change my mind.

See my comment elsewhere on the swiss model.

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by sp332 on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @08:31PM (#5678063)
Death isn't preventable, you can only delay it. Should the people pay for someone's heart surgery if their kidneys are on track to fail in a few months anyway?
Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by Klinky on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @09:29PM (#5678252)
Life expectancy estimates are often all over the board and wrong. Imagine it's a close relative who is having the heart surgery. Would you actively try to persuade them to not do the surgery to possibly extend their life because their kidneys might fail later, so they might as well die now because they're not worth the money that would go into the surgery?

It's easy to say a Big Mac isn't worth the cost on the menu, it's harder to say that your mom's life isn't worth the cost.

Keep in mind we're talking purely about economics here, as that is what your post is about. We're not talking about quality of life.

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by sp332 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @12:06AM (#5678761)
Economically speaking, I think it's fine for a person to spend huge amounts of their own money that way if they want. Also, it's fine if they ask around for friends, family, or even total strangers to finance their health. But forcing people to pay (via taxes) for an operation seems outrageous to me.
Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by Klinky on Thursday May 09, 2013 @12:27AM (#5678830)
Not really the point I was making. People will go to great lengths and effectively destroy their own life in the pursuit of saving a loved one. This makes it hard to take seriously the concept that a a free market full of economically rational consumers would exist when it comes to costly medical decisions.

It's easy to say "if you didn't want to be poor, you shouldn't have bought that plasma tv or new smartphone", versus "if you didn't want to be poor you should have let your wife die instead of taking a second mortgage out on your house".

Most people do not have a maximum price on something they consider priceless.

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by vidarh on Thursday May 09, 2013 @05:02AM (#5679439)
You benefit immensely from society. To expect you to pay some portion of your income to help that society function is not unreasonable, and extensive healthcare is consistently one of the things people in most developed societies see as one of the top priorities for society to spend that money on.

I'd fully support your right to opt out of taxes if you also opt out of each and every benefit society otherwise provides you.

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by sp332 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @09:01AM (#5680175)
If the government starts paying (at least some) of people's medical bills, there will be a committee somewhere that determines who is deserving of care and who is not.
Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by vidarh on Thursday May 09, 2013 @09:11AM (#5680230)
If the government doesn't, peoples finances decide who is deserving of care and who is not, which more often than not means an insurance company decides.

Personally I'm far more comfortable with a board under democratic control setting rules based on clinical considerations for whether or not someone is suitable for care, than having someone with a profit motive to avoid paying for my care making that decision.

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by sp332 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @09:21AM (#5680272)
You're more optimistic than I am if you think that a government committee will be democratic, or that such a committee (democratic or not) would base its decisions on clinical considerations, or that people would not be outraged at rational clinical decisions.

In general, I think this kind of decision is highly personal and dependent on circumstance, and cannot possibly be regulated at the federal level.

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by vidarh on Thursday May 09, 2013 @11:20AM (#5680874)
I am optimistic of that because I've lived all my 38 years in countries where all of those are the case for the most part, and where violations leads to lawsuits and heads rolling, resulting in health systems ranked substantially higher than the US, while costing less money per capita (UK and Norway).

In the UK this is handled by NICE: http://www.nice.org.uk/

They conduct appraisals of technology and medicine, and the NHS is required by law to provide treatments that NICE recommends.

The NHS trusts may elect to provide funding for additional treatments, though.

A number of their working groups etc. are open to healthcare professionals, and some are open to patient representatives, carers and lay people. Consultations are open to anyone. On top of that they are accountable to their sponsoring department.

Overall, this system works. You hear people complain about wait times for non-essential treatments, but everyone gets treated.

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by bane on Thursday May 09, 2013 @11:38AM (#5680991)
> You're more optimistic than I am if you think that a government committee will be democratic, or that such a committee (democratic or not) would base its decisions on clinical considerations, or that people would not be outraged at rational clinical decisions.

As opposed to the democratic decision that's already being made in board rooms?

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by sp332 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @12:41PM (#5681388)
It doesn't have to be democratic because it's not using the public's money.
Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by bane on Thursday May 09, 2013 @01:53PM (#5681891)
oh I see, so long as people are killed by private money it's cool.
Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by sp332 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @02:03PM (#5681956)
Oh, so as long as people are "killed" democratically it's cool.

Nobody's killing anybody. People die. It happens. Maybe someday I will have a heart attack. On that day, I'm not going to rob somebody at gunpoint and demand they give me $33k. Equivalently, I'm not going to have the government threaten fellow citizens with jail time and garnished wages if they don't pay their taxes to pay for my treatment. And I'd appreciate it if they'd extend me the same respect.

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by bane on Thursday May 09, 2013 @02:19PM (#5682077)
You know what? You're right. Fuck it. People die. Let's not even bother. Let's cut out the police department, the military...even if you did have the money, why bother? You're just going to die.

Why bother eating right or exercising? Fuck, why not just off ourselves and save all the hassle.

There's absolutely no difference amongst the different kinds of things people can die from, especially ones that are easy to fix and ones that we can't do anything about.

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by sp332 on Thursday May 09, 2013 @02:27PM (#5682125)
There's absolutely no difference amongst the different kinds of things people can die from, especially ones that are easy to fix and ones that we can't do anything about.

Hey, we actually came back to the point, kinda! There's a lot of things you can die from that fall in between "easy to fix" and "can't do anything about it". Where you draw the "fuck it, people die" line is hugely variable between different people, and it's not something you'll find a shred of consensus on across the 300,000,000 people in the USA. It's better for people to negotiate coverage with individual hospitals (and voluntary charities) than to have standards of care dictated by a central authority.

Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by bane on Thursday May 09, 2013 @02:39PM (#5682198)
apparently it's provably not since countries with a strong centrally controlled health care system seem to be providing superior health care vs systems that let people do what you propose
Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by bane on Thursday May 09, 2013 @11:37AM (#5680982)
there already is, and always has been
Re:Your heart attack bill: $3,300 in Arkansas, $92,000 in Ca... by mikeash on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @09:04PM (#5678176)
I don't know, but people in general seem to think the answer is "yes". Until and unless that changes, market forces won't really work in health care.