News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Failed Startup, unreasonable clients, where do I go from here?

I put it all on the line on a startup that had good traction, but very low revenue per user, and ended up selling it for a pittance when I couldn't meet obligations. In the end I was dead broke.

I know many would say I didn't manage my finances properly, but at the start I was fresh out of college with no marketable skills and at the end I was a competent developer. Importantly I was so frugal I lived under the poverty level the entire time.

I went into consulting, and worked for a client that despite promises always managed to maneuver into only paying subsistence wages.

I got more jobs, but only from more unreasonable clients, and I made the rookie mistake of charging a flat rate for projects. The scope always expands with these clients.

I got smarter and changed the structure of my business after watching this video called F*ck you Pay Me: http://vimeo.com/22053820

It has been working, the response I get from clients is much better, but I still have not been able to break into the $100+ hour market.

I thought I had found the job that would allow me to break out from this cycle of desperation around rent due dates, pay off the debt I accrued with my startup etc... And start running a serious and professional consultancy.

I did a phone interview, and they were excited and I went in to speak to four people, and at that meeting they said they were ready to go and that we could get started right away.

And then nothing. No response to email. Nothing. I feel sort of crushed by the flakiness. I know I am only one good client away from all of this changing, but it feels right now like it's never going to happen.

I was wondering if other developers have had similar experiences. I'm competent at what I do, it gets better, right?

( 12 comments | 10 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Failed Startup, unreasonable clients, where do I ... by tptacek on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @12:27PM (#5675118)
Maybe you could go into a little more detail about how your previous clients managed to weasel out of paying.

Maybe you could tell us a little bit more about how you scoped those projects and how you handled contracts and payment terms.

It would definitely help if you told us how you sourced those clients. Did you network your way into them, or get them off outsourcing sites?

How big were the clients?

You're not one good client away from all your problems changing; you're several business model changes away from having a sustainable business that will generate fewer abusive relationships, and, over the long term, the luxury of being picky about your clients.

Re:Ask HN: Failed Startup, unreasonable clients, where do I ... by larrys on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @01:29PM (#5675572)
"from having a sustainable business that will generate fewer abusive relationships"

As in relationships with women|men I have found that you can usually spot the pains in the asses as tips of the iceberg way before anything is signed or any job is started or on the first dates. The question is of course do certain people have the skills to spot the warning signs (in context of course and not over react) and some don't? And just like the desire for sex causes people to act irrationally and ignore warning signs does the need for money do the same?

FWIW, I had a developer who did a 60k project for us about 7 years ago that wanted no money down at all. After he and his team did a fair amount of work we insisted on sending him $15k. I felt bad for him. I guess he didn't have enough experience to know what could happen. Project was successful, he did more work and was paid more and is currently given about $500/m for just being on hand to answer his cell phone in case of any issues. Which he does.

Re:Ask HN: Failed Startup, unreasonable clients, where do I ... by blitzen on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @01:02PM (#5675375)
> Maybe you could go into a little more detail about how your previous clients managed to weasel out of paying.

Expanding scope and holding final payment hostage.

> Maybe you could tell us a little bit more about how you scoped those projects and how you handled contracts and payment terms.

List of requirements, with 50% before and 50% when done. This was my #1 mistake and I have stopped this.

> It would definitely help if you told us how you sourced those clients. Did you network your way into them, or get them off outsourcing sites?

Networking.

> How big were the clients?

Larger side of small business scale.

> You're not one good client away from all your problems changing; you're several business model changes away from having a sustainable business that will generate fewer abusive relationships, and, over the long term, the luxury of being picky about your clients.

One month at $100+ an hour would take care of all debts, allow me to purchase needed medicine and provide enough runway to only accept quality clients. That is what I meant by that.

Re:Ask HN: Failed Startup, unreasonable clients, where do I ... by tptacek on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @04:02PM (#5676496)
First suggestion: any client that plays games with payment is a client you can't afford to keep. It's a bit of a judgement call; maybe they saw their scope extension as reasonable and in the spirit of the original engagement.

Second suggestion: split your contracts up; your first contract is your "Master", and your second a "Statement of Work" (SOW). Both require execution by both sides before you proceed. Don't work without an explicit SOW again. The SOW should list in bullets the whole scope of the project and the acceptance criteria, and list the payment schedule.

You need to be able to tell you client "OK, but to do that we'll need to put in place a new SOW" when they try to extend scope.

We don't ask for up-front payment at all, and I'm not wild about it (if you really need it, you have crappy clients, and should fix that instead of coming up with ways to mitigate crappy clients). But since you do:

Next suggestion: by the time a client has paid you 50% for a project, you now hold all the cards. They can't afford to have you walk away with an incomplete deliverable and write off the cost of the engagement. So next time this happens, just say "no" to scope extensions (politely!) and see what happens.

You might be surprised at how much more effective you are at negotiating if you go into these things knowing you have the leverage and not them.

Re:Ask HN: Failed Startup, unreasonable clients, where do I ... by jaz on Friday May 10, 2013 @08:21AM (#5685777)
What is typically contained in the master contract? Things such as payment terms?
Re:Ask HN: Failed Startup, unreasonable clients, where do I ... by cpncrunch on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @01:26PM (#5675550)
I do a fair bit of this sort of contract work. I normally either charge $100/hr or give a fixed price. For project work I normally charge a fixed price, but I make sure I get a reasonably detailed spec before doing this (and I insist on not doing any more work without further pay, unless it's very minor stuff).

Note that I've got 20+ years experience, and ALL of my contract work comes through my website (collaborative whiteboard/conferencing software) - normally it is customizing the software to the customer's requirements.

It's very difficult just finding this sort of contract work unless you have some way to funnel in new customers. In your case I'd recommend maybe just taking on a full-time on-site contract job.

Re:Ask HN: Failed Startup, unreasonable clients, where do I ... by blitzen on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @01:50PM (#5675694)
Thank you. It's the best bet. I am going to pursue that today.
Re:Ask HN: Failed Startup, unreasonable clients, where do I ... by hbien on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @02:53PM (#5676095)
I was in the exact same boat.

I've charged project fees and ended up making under $10/hour. I've also undercharged ($30/hour), have agreed to work weekends on some contracts, and have collected payments that are MONTHS late or never even arrive.

It got better. All of the above problems happened because I let it happen (charged too low, not use contracts, always saying yes for fear of losing money).

Here's what I did: play the ladder game by increasing your rate slowly after every client/contract, try daily/weekly rates, avoid clients with red flags, use referrals. Read Brennan Dunn's "Double Your Freelancing Rate" and "The Wealthy Freelancer".

For me, it wasn't an overnight switch to a new client that made it better. It was a lot of slow changes that built up momentum.

[deleted]
Re:Ask HN: Failed Startup, unreasonable clients, where do I ... by blitzen on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @12:09PM (#5675007)
Thank you for responding.

What I have been doing wrong is charging a flat rate for projects that is too low. Then the clients hold the final payment hostage while asking for unending changes.

I got smarter in my latest jobs, but they were only very small ones for low money. I have only been earning $15 per hour.

I would be incredibly happy to make $50 per hour for 3 months. I think my next best bet is to contact dev shops in my city that have clients already.

Re:Ask HN: Failed Startup, unreasonable clients, where do I ... by danielweber on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @01:51PM (#5675700)
Then the clients hold the final payment hostage while asking for unending changes

How much of your work did they have at this point? The client should be discouraged from adding more and more work because it delays them getting their website/software/app in their own possession.

Re:Ask HN: Failed Startup, unreasonable clients, where do I ... by blitzen on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @02:09PM (#5675826)
For one client they had the entirety because they insisted on me making changes to a live production system (I know, crazy)

In another case they seemed to be happy to continue using their legacy system until the new one was perfect in their eyes.

Re:Ask HN: Failed Startup, unreasonable clients, where do I ... by sharemywin on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @01:31PM (#5675587)
Not sure what country and/or skillset you have but I would think you could get a job or contract to hire for $30-$50/hr in most of the US.