News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by wwweston on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @05:59PM (#5671109)
> Fitzgerald wrote what he did expecting the copyright protections available at the time.

Well, OK. That just proves he didn't need 70 to "forever less one day" in order to write it.

But the evidence is strongly on the side that he needed at least 50 years. I mean, did you see him writing Gatsby before the 1909 copyright act? No, you didn't, because before that, he'd have somewhere around 40 piddling years of copyright protection. But the 1909 act passes and sure enough, Gatsby comes out less than 15 years later.

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by jlgreco on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:07PM (#5671146)
Are you for real? Fitzgerald did not right the Great Gatsby before 1909 because in 1909 he was 13 years old.

If you have any sources about Fitzgerald's take on copyright terms I would love to read them, but without that you have absolutely no basis with which to say that there is "strong evidence" that he required more than 50 years.

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by wiredfool on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:08PM (#5671154)
If you sit on a novel or other creative work worth mentioning in any short list of the Great American $foo because 40 years of protection isn't enough, then you're not an artist. As if 10 more years makes the difference between releasing and not releasing a great work of art.

I'll also point out that it's hard to write about the roaring '20s before the Copyright act of 1909.

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by wwweston on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @07:03PM (#5671442)
> I'll also point out that it's hard to write about the roaring '20s before the Copyright act of 1909.

Yep. It's almost as if such an argument would be too absurd to take seriously.

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by derleth on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:33PM (#5671293)
> I'll also point out that it's hard to write about the roaring '20s before the Copyright act of 1909.

Through Copyright, All Things Are Possible!

Hail Copyright!

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by Jtsummers on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:07PM (#5671144)
How is that evidence? Considering that much of the content of the book was based on the time it was written and published in, it would not have been written in 1909.

Is my sarcasm detector off? Or are you just a really bizarre troll?

Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by akgerber on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:17PM (#5671188)
Your sarcasm detector is off.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by jlgreco on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:25PM (#5671225)
I don't know; Poe's Law makes it hard. When there are people that actually believe things that absurd, it becomes to discern intent without some side channels (that are mostly missing when communicating with text).
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by darkarmani on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @12:36AM (#5672501)
That's why Windows 3.11 wasn't written until after the Sunny Bono act. Just think if we had strong copyright in the 50s. That's probably why we don't have flying cars yet.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by jopof on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @11:39PM (#5672350)
Sarcasm doesn't work on the Internet.
Re:Why Isn't Gatsby in the Public Domain? by noptic on Wednesday May 08, 2013 @04:13AM (#5673100)
Are you positive that this is a internet issue? I think it is a user problem.