Have you ever used a collections agency?
(Not challenging you; you just said you've collected lots of debts, and I'm interested in your experience. I've been a witness to a couple incidents, but I don't have a lot of experience.)
Yes, I've been to small claims court 15-20 times. I won every time.
Folks who force you to go to SCC in the first place tend to be flakes, therefore they tend to not even show up. 75% of the cases that I've had, and that I've witnessed, in SCC, only have 1 party show, and that party wins by default (at least in MA).
> Have you ever used a collections agency?
Not yet. I plan to, though.
Why on Earth not? Make empty threats!
What are you afraid of, that these guys will learn that you're capable of bluffing and then push you around? That appears to have happened already.
Though I actually agree that you shouldn't bluff a lawsuit. You should give fair warning and then file the lawsuit. What are you waiting for, someone to cheat you out of twenty thousand bucks?
1) find a lawyer who you can hire for an hour or two for $200-$400. You're paying for his letterhead, not his skills.
2) Get him to write a letter saying "you have 14 days to pay 2/3 of the amount. If we receive that, the debt is discharged in full. IF we don't receive that by 14 days from today, we're going to court, and we're asking for the full amount of the debt, lawyer fees, and damages. Please pay now."
I've collected LOTS of debts in my time, 95% successfully.
This technique works.