Re:Traffic From Syria Disappears From Internet
by Jabbles on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @05:52PM
(#5671074)
Re-merging does not work like that. All Syrian transactions will effectively be reversed. That's assuming that they managed to mine anything, with such a small fraction of the usual computing power available.
Re:Traffic From Syria Disappears From Internet
by Anderkent on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:03PM
(#5671120)
The difficulty level adjusts to the mining power. And only transactions that were double-spent will be reversed, since nodes will re-broadcast transactions from the short chain onto the long chain, and those that weren't double spent will be accepted.
Re:Traffic From Syria Disappears From Internet
by teraflop on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @07:11PM
(#5671483)
There's another important class of transactions that are reversed: mining outputs. In order to accept a payment from someone while isolated from the network, you have to carefully check that all the coins they're sending you were generated before the split, or else those coins will evaporate at some point in the future.
Re:Traffic From Syria Disappears From Internet
by eurleif on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:32PM
(#5671279)
>The difficulty level adjusts to the mining power.
But difficulty adjustments occur every 2016 blocks, not instantly. https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Difficulty#How_often_does_the_dif...
Re:Traffic From Syria Disappears From Internet
by cookiecaper on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @09:14PM
(#5671904)
Assuming that we can just reconnect the segments after a brief downtime, like we do now if a backhoe accidentally hits the line into your apartment complex or something. Such a situation is not necessarily so simply resolved in wartime, when opposing factions have a serious interest in depriving telecomms from one another.
Re:Traffic From Syria Disappears From Internet
by tomkarlo on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:29PM
(#5671255)
If we dropped you into the middle of Syria right now, would you rather have:
1. $10,000 in USD currency
2. $10,000 USD equiv in gold
3. $10,000 USD equiv in bitcoin
I'm pretty sure the only practical answer is (1). That pretty much answers your question (2).
Re:Traffic From Syria Disappears From Internet
by brador on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @06:56PM
(#5671411)
Interesting. But if 1. Was not available would you rather have 2. Or 3.?
Re:Traffic From Syria Disappears From Internet
by tomkarlo on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @07:16PM
(#5671501)
Obviously 2. Bitcoin is pretty useless if you don't have a dependable electrical grid or internet. I'd rather have $10,000 in USD, EUR or GLD than $1M in Bitcoin in a war zone where I had no other funds. Heck, I'd rather have gasoline or coffee than bitcoin.
2) You think REGULAR currencies have much more value than cryptocurrencies during these types of crises?
3) If Syria hypothetically still has a working "intranet" but not a working "internet", then Bitcoin will continue working just fine for them while they're not connected to the rest of us. After the Syrians re-connect, their branch will be withered, but not dead. Re-merging will be automatic when the Internet returns.