News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by ebbv on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @08:01AM (#5667622)
Pass me whatever you're smoking, bud.

> I doubt anyone at Microsoft is that upset about Windows 8's reception

You are wrong. I mean, I'm sure there are people at Microsoft who don't care. Windows 8 is a failure so far. They need to salvage it.

This teenage attitude of it being "weak" to fix it and "cave" to consumer demands doesn't cut it when you're talking about a multi-billion dollar product completely failing in a publicly traded company. Microsoft has a legal obligation to its investors to fix this problem.

> but I don't see any significant reversal of direction

Again, you're wrong.

They're releasing a patch to add in boot to desktop and reintroduce the start button. The only thing they aren't undoing yet is giving a traditional start menu instead of the start screen.

Consumers have spoken clearly; they don't like or want Windows 8. It doesn't matter if it's better in your opinion. It's a product for the masses. It's a product for Mom & Dad, they need to be able to use it. And that means that abandoning all the established visual dialogue is a stupid mistake.

The lack of sales has shown that, and it's why Microsoft is reversing direction and releasing this patch.

There's a reason this news is being covered in the Financial Times; because investors see lack of Windows 8 sales and they get very unhappy.

Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by corporalagumbo on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @08:08AM (#5667648)
You might be right - like I said, I think they will try to smooth the desktop-metro split, which was handled clumsily in Windows 8. Again, I think it's a start of a long transition for Microsoft (and the industry in general) and so I don't think it is surprising that there were rough patches.

As far as the "consumers have spoken", perhaps they have, but I don't advocate Microsoft staying the course out of some teenage idea of not admitting failure. I advocate it because the potential OS that could evolve from the foundation started with Windows 8 is the only feasible long-term option if Microsoft is to remain competitive over the next ten years.

Consumers are short-sighted, and currently the problem for Microsoft is, in a nutshell, maintaining legacy support gracefully while continuing to progress towards the new paradigm.

Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by nhebb on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @08:55AM (#5667847)
I sell Windows desktop software, so I decided to check my visitor stats for the past month. It's been 7 months since Windows 8 was released and less than 5% of my Windows visitors are running Win8. I checked the same time frame after Windows 7 was released, and roughly 13% of my visitors were running Win7. If i had that big of a sales drop, I'd be looking inward, not outward.

Windows 8 may be a visionary change taking Microsoft into the future. The problem, though, is that it's a tablet vision being applied to a desktop system.

I'm a Windows consumer that doesn't like Windows 8. I don't think I'm short sighted. I'm just trying to get work done.

Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by jmh42 on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @11:15AM (#5668512)
This is horrible analysis: comparing Vista to windows 7 changes to windows 7 to 8 changes.

Vista was arguably Microsoft's worst OS. Windows 7 arguably the best. Obviously the changes you mention would be better. In fact, with 5% I am amazed and think that is rather impressive.

Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by vyrotek on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @11:49AM (#5668716)
Just thought I'd share this.

11.65 percent of Steam owners used Windows 8 in April

http://www.neowin.net/news/1165-percent-of-steam-owners-used...

Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by greedo on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @08:46AM (#5667794)
"As far as the "consumers have spoken", perhaps they have,"

"Consumers are short-sighted"

If only consumers could see the true beauty that Microsoft has created. If they only knew what was best for them.

Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by corporalagumbo on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @08:51AM (#5667831)
You're arguing against a strawman, not me. Try reading my other comments in this thread.
Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by greedo on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @09:18AM (#5667945)
Those are direct quotes from your comments. If you want to retcon them, fine. All I see is a huge set of assertions from you, and now a lot of backpedaling as your arguments are being dismantled.
Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by corporalagumbo on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @04:53PM (#5670709)
No, you're completely mistaken sorry.
Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by VikingCoder on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @08:52AM (#5667836)
I don't understand why you say "A company like Microsoft... has really, really carefully thought through its plans... [but?] the desktop-metro split... was handled clumsily in Windows 8."

I'm connecting whole thoughts of yours unfairly to show how fundamentally contradictory those two thoughts are. The desktop-metro split was, in my opinion, absolutely the most important part of Windows 8, that they HAD to get right, and upon which its entire success or failure would be based.

Do you disagree with my assertion that the desktop-metro split was the most important aspect of Windows 8? Isn't Microsoft the kind of company that "really, really carefully [thinks] through its plans"?

So then why was it handled clumsily?

Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by corporalagumbo on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @05:09PM (#5670800)
It was handled clumsily because the Windows team had to move fast and break things. Windows 8 has a lot of pretty important under the hood changes. And it's no trivial feat to try and develop and implement a future-proof new UI style that can be layered over the old system. Anyway, this comparison is apples to oranges: Microsoft's top level long-term strategic vision compared to the Windows' team's short-term execution.

You might argue that the Windows team dropped the ball and didn't get enough right with this release. I would agree that they didn't get everything right, but long term I see the specific success of Windows 8 being of little consequence to the company - simply because future releases will continue to build on every aspect of Windows 8, as, out of the current Cambrian soup of a halfway OS, confused consumers and eclectic OEM devices, a new consensus about how computers should work is forged.

Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by simba-hiiipower on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @08:53AM (#5667838)
uh…

> Consumers have spoken clearly; they don't like or want Windows 8.

any evidence to back that up..? if anything, it seems the 'masses' are just fine with it and its tech geeks that are most bothered.. Microsoft just announced that they've passed 100 million Windows 8 licenses sold in the six months since launch, which is on-par with where Windows 7 was at this point in its lifecycle.

> The lack of sales has shown that, and it's why Microsoft is reversing direction and releasing this patch.

again, no. if anything, i'd say Windows 8 sales are rather impressive given they’re matching the pace of Windows 7 which came following a poorly received Vista.. you'd think that a release following a very popular and stable release (7 to 8) would see comparatively less traction than one following a poor one (Vista to 7), but it’s still holding-up, and doing so in a declining PC market farcing a number of other external forces.

> There's a reason this news is being covered in the Financial Times; because investors see lack of Windows 8 sales and they get very unhappy.

not true. just because it’s the FT reporting doesn't mean it’s any more insightful than your typical tech blog or speak for investor sentiment, at all. MSFT shares have been performing rather well since the launch of Windows 8. either way, Microsoft is a large and increasingly diversified company, so i wouldn't put too much weight in that one way or another. you make it sound like this is the largest product flop in the history of the world.. very sensational, also very not untrue.

Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by ebbv on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @09:05AM (#5667888)
The evidence is sales for it stink.

Microsoft just released the numbers and it's only selling at half the rate of Windows 7. (Win7 averaged 20mil/mo, Win8 is averaging 10.)

And sales should be HIGHER following a successful release than a failed one. People were skeptical of Windows 7 when it came out because Vista had gotten so much flack. Everybody liked 7 so a solid follow up to it should have sold well.

Also you missed my point about FT, I wasn't saying that FT is more insightful. Certainly it isn't when it comes to tech stuff. But it's in the FT because investors are concerned about what Microsoft is doing, and Microsoft wants the FT to report that they are releasing a fix patch for Windows 8 to calm investors down.

edit:

Also keep in mind that those Windows 8 sales numbers include sales of Windows 8 RT and Windows 8 on Surface Pros. Granted sales for those devices are not great either, but it's inflating Windows 8 numbers when comparing them to Windows 7 numbers; it's not an apples to apples comparison.

Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by simba-hiiipower on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:04AM (#5668171)
maybe i’m just dense, but i’m not following youth logic or your math here..

numbers have been officially reported at two intervals: 60 million sold as of January 2013 [1], and 100 million as of May 2013 [2]. both points indicate its performing fairly well, and just shy of its predecessor. while not ideal, achieving these volumes is most certainly not so catastrophic that ‘investors’ are getting worried. if anything, they appear to be rewarding the company for taking steps to adapt early-on (relatively speaking).

as for sales needing to be higher following a successful release, that’s most certainly not true as a general rule and in this particular case doesn’t make sense either. we're not talking about movie release.. a PC (and, by extension, Windows to most) is a utility, not a discretionary good. most people depend on it in some form or another and if their PC isn't performing adequately to accomplish some task, they upgrade; if it’s fine, they stick it out until need be.. in the case of Vista to 7, many people were plagued with issues and in-need of new PCs (and a more stable OS), hence the rapid rate at which it sold. today, a PC running 7 from a few years back is still fairly capable and the need to upgrade is less pronounced. that it especially true if people are spending less time on a PC as many consumption-related activities can be transferred to other devices like smartphones and tablets.

speaking of which, keep in mind how much has changed since 7 was released.. people are now holding-on to their PCs for longer periods of time and there is increased competition from tablets and smartphones. the market is in decline, i’m not arguing against that, but pointing to 8 as the culprit is inaccurate.

[1] http://blogs.windows.com/windows/b/bloggingwindows/archive/2...

[2] http://blogs.windows.com/windows/b/bloggingwindows/archive/2...

edit: sales numbers are never that comparable, and its been three years.. for all the reasons listed above, they're not comparable.. introducing surface into the mix also makes them less comparable..

my point has less to do with specific milestones and more so to the point that by no reasonable standard could you call the product a failure so far. and projecting your particular dissatisfaction with the changes made (or maybe just a general grudge against the company, i don't know?) to the 'masses' is inaccurate and doesn't add any real value.

Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by illuminate on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @10:08AM (#5668202)
"And sales should be HIGHER following a successful release than a failed one."

Sorry, no. People don't upgrade their OS as often if the previous one "just works", no matter how many bells and whistles are added.

Re:Microsoft prepares U-turn on Windows 8 by parasubvert on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @09:18AM (#5667949)
Consider what's behind these numbers...

- The whole point of Windows 8 was to make massive inroads into tablets with the Surface and other OEM models; that's not happening at the rate they hoped

- The PC market is clearly shrinking at an increased rate due to pressure from the smartphone, iPad and other tablets.

So in summary, the growth rates of the iPad, Win 2008 licenses shouldn't be flat - they should be up. These are the charts that worries Microsoft:

http://www.asymco.com/2013/05/01/surface-tension-the-effect-...

Not a bleak picture yet, but not roses either.