News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Linux is not about choice (2008) by coldtea on Monday May 06, 2013 @09:43PM (#5666062)
>It really isn't. Unless you have a card without a driver (exceedingly rare, though it's not uncommon to need a recent kernel to use recent hardware) ALSA pretty much Just Works. For complex features like streaming sound over the network you need PulseAudio, which due to its complexity takes more configuration and setup, but that's done out of the box on a fair number of distros.

So, in other words, it really is. All you said was just rephrasing the problem as solved.

For one, what's "exceedingly rare" is not getting any sound at all. That doesn't mean you get to enjoy all the features of your soundcard (from mixing panels to 3D audio and such). Or that it work without tinkering in ALL programs and across desktop environments.

There's also the issue of more professional sound work, which will be a world of pain. Getting any pro, multi-channel soundcards to work and such.

For anything else than basic sound playing, from recording a podcast, to streaming, to using a DAW etc, here be dragons.

Re:Linux is not about choice (2008) by cageface on Monday May 06, 2013 @10:11PM (#5666168)
The dog's breakfast of audio standards on Linux neatly encapsulates the weaknesses of systems as open and democratic as Linux and illustrates why it thrives on servers where these issues are less pressing and still languishes on the desktop where too much choice is not a virtue.

This legacy hampers Android too, which is a joke when it comes to multimedia APIs compared to the oligarchic iOS.

Re:Linux is not about choice (2008) by cookiecaper on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @03:48PM (#5670307)
Desktop Linux is just missing a vertical here. The "open and democratic" methods of Linux, also called "free market" or "bazaar", are a fine as a stage of development. This is why distributions exist; they make the choices from the raw technology and bundle it up all neatly. The issue is that the distributions do not have a real attitude of tight integration and strict user-centric organizational imperatives. Ubuntu, Fedora, et al use their platforms as late-stage testbeds instead of standardized, consumer-ready desktop burns with full integration.

In many ways, OS X has shown us the ideal distribution. It's based on open technology and continually adopts new technology as it proves itself, but Apple is not afraid to integrate tightly and replace components with well-engineered, well-tested replacements as necessary (the origination of the divergence between X11 and Quartz), as long as it means a solid, unified, consistent and functional experience for their users.

We need that now. Canonical fancies themselves after that pattern but I don't believe they take the needed organization seriously enough and I don't believe they have the technical expertise necessary to really make the tough calls and implement a technically-sound user-centric system (see: Mir). They need to get some new leadership in there.