News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by mc-lovin on Monday May 06, 2013 @08:01PM (#5665595)
As someone who generally believes in free markets, I am already unsympathetic to these people. However the venom directed at tech employees strikes me as something more than just economics.

People are having a go at nerds because they can. The scales of social status haven't changed since high school, but it turns out that nerds can earn a good salary, and in the "fascist" free market economy, this means they can live where they like, and the police will even protect them!

I wish I knew about this so I could show up in my Google sweater.

Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by potatolicious on Monday May 06, 2013 @09:03PM (#5665869)
> "I wish I knew about this so I could show up in my Google sweater."

I disagree very much with your notion that this is people pummeling at nerds because of some remnant of high school social pecking order, but please don't do this.

This is the corner of 16th and Mission. The local police station is literally two blocks away and still have zero control over this intersection. It is a mad house. It is the Mos Eisley of San Francisco.

The level of class warfare (from both sides) in the Mission is pretty intense, and the area is already a bit lawless to the point where the police have little control over an open-air drug den just two blocks from the station house. You don't fuck around with that intersection, the cops can't protect you well there, and everyone knows it.

Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by mc-lovin on Monday May 06, 2013 @09:34PM (#5666015)
You seem to know much more about this situation than me, but given my experience in the left, I would be very surprised if the people involved in an open air drug den had much to do with the people attending and organizing this protest.

And there seems to be a discrepancy between the extreme danger you claim I would be in, and the claims of other people that this is a harmless gathering. Can you shed some light on this? No sarcasm intended there, I really am surprised by how you characterize the situation because in my experience, no one provoking left wingers is ever in serious danger.

Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by potatolicious on Monday May 06, 2013 @09:48PM (#5666084)
These aren't left wingers in the liberal left winger sense. Practically everyone in San Francisco is a liberal left winger. These are militant left wingers (the photos of the event seem to suggest this, based on my experiences in the neighborhood). I would not be surprised if there were more than a few violent folks in the crowd.

Keep in mind what happened the last time there was an anti-gentrification protest in the Mission. Ostensibly it's a peaceful gathering to march against gentrification. It turned into smashing windows of local independent businesses and massive vandalism.

Every leftist protest or demonstration in San Francisco seems to have a bad habit of turning violent. This isn't to say that everyone there is violent, or that their cause isn't worthwhile, but rather that if you see these marches or protests, the Black Bloc is always close at hand, so I'd watch right the fuck out.

> "I would be very surprised if the people involved in an open air drug den had much to do with the people attending and organizing this protest."

There's not much of an intersection. The whole open-air drug den thing isn't to associate the protesters with the crackheads of the neighborhood, but rather to say that this isn't like any street corner in San Francisco. This is a street corner that the police effectively have no control over. If you get jumped by a Black Bloc asshole with a bone to pick with Googlers, you are fending for yourself. Though, reading the article, it looks like the cops were on hand for this one, which is a nice change for the corner of 16th and Mission.

All in all, don't be so cavalier with your own safety. While San Francisco isn't ruled by the Khmer Rouge, the Mission is not a safe neighborhood. Don't let the bistros and boutique coffee shops fool you. If you mind your own business you'll be fine. If you go looking for trouble, the Mission has no problem delivering trouble to your face, fast.

Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by mc-lovin on Monday May 06, 2013 @10:00PM (#5666120)
You make some good points, and I will bear them in mind when dealing with these people.

However, what you say makes the complaints by the protesters about the heavy police presence seem ridiculous: it cannot be the case that this protest is "peaceful" and yet anyone present who appears to be against hem would be in serious danger.

Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by potatolicious on Monday May 06, 2013 @10:17PM (#5666183)
Even disregarding the personal danger aspect, the police presence is well justified simply by looking at similar protests in the past. A bunch of people rallying around hating another group of people is, following San Francisco patterns, highly likely to result in violence, property destruction, vandalism, or some combination of the above.

I feel very much that the Black Bloc and anarchist protesters that infest every cause and protest in San Francisco is a huge part of why the city is the way it is. Otherwise legitimate, worthwhile causes can garner no public support because a highly visible minority of their base takes every chance they get to smash shit up. They become politically untenable to support for city politicians lest they look like they are soft on crime - because protesting is synonymous with crime thanks to these people. They also drive away moderates as no one really wants to be caught on the wrong side of a riot (is there a right side to being in a riot?).

Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by gruseom on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @01:45AM (#5666671)
I lived in the Mission for many years and I find your description overwrought.
Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by tptacek on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @09:25AM (#5667980)
Really? When did you live in SF?
Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by beatpanda on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @01:10AM (#5666612)
Meanwhile, I hang out there on Thursday nights and I've never had a problem. Love it, in fact.
Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by sp332 on Monday May 06, 2013 @08:10PM (#5665638)
There's a difference between free-market economics and saying that poorer people don't deserve a voice in local government because they don't have money. I don't believe a particular public sidewalk should get preferential treatment just because richer people walk on it.
Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by mc-lovin on Monday May 06, 2013 @08:13PM (#5665654)
How do poorer people lack a voice in local government? It seems to me their issue is that they want to extend their control over local affairs far beyond what is their right. It is simply not the right of local residents to determine what kind of person gets to live in that neighborhood. This was a block "party" to make a very specific kind of person feel unwelcome. And then they think of themselves as oppressed when the police break it up.
Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by markdown on Monday May 06, 2013 @08:51PM (#5665817)
> How do poorer people lack a voice in local government? ... And then they think of themselves as oppressed when the police break it up.

Police breaking up a non-violent protest of only 40 people... yes, that's the definition of oppression. I don't like what you have to say so I'll shut you up is oppression.

Have you ever read your constitution? These people are douchebags, but what they were doing should not have been stopped.

Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by mc-lovin on Monday May 06, 2013 @08:58PM (#5665847)
I agree with you about the right to protest. I wasn't aware that was an issue: pretty sure that's not what the person I was replying to was talking about. Certainly none of the articles on the issue claimed that the police were acting outside the law. Maybe the guy beating a pinata with a pole was the issue, I don't know.
[deleted]
Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by jopof on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @12:27AM (#5666514)
Depends who is cleaning the area -- government, or shop owners?
Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by a3n on Monday May 06, 2013 @09:20PM (#5665957)
This is A against B. B may or may not be affecting A negatively, but A is having a negative experience, and it's bad enough that they'll protest against anyone that seems related to the problem.

What you should be worried about is groups of people angry at groups of people. Protests, jostling, fights, deaths.

Showing up in your Google sweater is just fanning the flames, irresponsible and unempathetic. These people have a problem, and it's real to them. You might want to keep that sweater at the bottom of a drawer, lest it get caught on a pitchfork and burned by a torch. I'll feel sorry for you (I will) as you unjustly burn.

Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by mc-lovin on Monday May 06, 2013 @09:39PM (#5666036)
Perhaps group B have legitimate complaints, but I somehow doubt they are serious enough to justify violence against anyone who makes light of their "struggle".

If it's true that these people have organized an event where someone would be physically assaulted for wearing a Google sweater (if there were no police there) then that's precisely why I would want to do it. People have a right to express themselves, they don't have a right to make other people feel unsafe.

Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by vacri on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @12:12AM (#5666478)
Hearing that you would knowingly and consciously choose to antagonise upset people for absolutely no reason beyond your own entertainment, I am already unsympathetic to you should the situation escalate beyond your control.
Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by mc-lovin on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @12:39AM (#5666541)
The funny thing is, I never considered when I posted that that there would be violence beyond the usual getting in your face that I've seen at left wing protests.

Why does the fact that these people are upset make their cause any more just? Why do my rights (and more importantly the rights of any tech employees who might happen to pass through there) end where their feelings begin?

Also, how sympathetic would you feel towards a Black man who "antagonized" white people by passing through a White neighborhood, and was attacked by Whites who were already upset by the civil rights movement.

Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by vacri on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @03:37AM (#5666922)
Please stop with the libertarian slogans. It's not about ending your rights or those of the passersby. It's about a set of people being upset, and you wishing you were there - willing to go out of your way - to upset them further.

These people are upset with change. Hard luck to them, I never said their cause was just. But you antagonising them has nothing to do with anything but your own amusement. I wouldn't condone physical violence for you wearing a particular sweater - and if you notice, I never suggested that I did. I merely used your high-horse dismissive language against you: I would be unsympathetic to you should you run into trouble. If you went out of your way to antagonise aggressive, upset people just for your own jollies, I'm not going to coddle you and say "there there, poor guy, those mean protesters".

If a kid sticks a knife into a power socket and gets seriously hurt, I'll be sympathetic. But if an adult does a Jackass-style "won't this be fun!" version and gets seriously hurt, no, I won't be sympathetic. I'll call an ambulance and apply first aid, but why should I care how that adult feels because they got hurt knowingly doing something stupid?

Also, how sympathetic would you feel towards a Black man who "antagonized" white people by passing through a White neighborhood

"I wish I knew about this [so I could go and antagonise them]" is not merely 'passing through'.

Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by mc-lovin on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @04:06AM (#5666989)
You misunderstood my use of the term "unsympathetic".

I meant it in the sense of being unsympathetic towards an opinion (the opinion that there is something unjust about gentrification) not towards the alleged victims of gentrification.

My aim is to express an opinion: That tech workers have a right to live where they want to, and that it's not the right of the local community, or people claiming to represent them, to stop them living where they choose to and frequenting the businesses they choose to.

Now this might be upsetting to people who think of themselves as victims of gentrification, but I didn't formulate this viewpoint for the purpose of upsetting them. If I have to change my viewpoint, or choose not to express it, because someone finds it upsetting, then that is not freedom of speech.

So unless you think that people should be forced to curtail their speech and keep their opinions to themselves, whenever that opinion is offensive to someone who has (or feels they have) suffered some ill fortune, you should stop comparing what I proposed to do with willfully inciting violence towards myself.

Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by caseydurfee on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @03:01PM (#5670031)
"If I have to change my viewpoint, or choose not to express it, because someone finds it upsetting, then that is not freedom of speech."

I don't think you really understand that "freedom of speech" refers to the actions of the government. It has nothing to do with what private citizens do in response to what you say. The first amendment doesn't protect you from blowback and it's not supposed to. Freedom of speech is not freedom from criticism.

However if you consider freedom of speech an issue between citizens, wouldn't the right to bear arms be the greatest enemy of freedom of speech? Seems like "an armed society is a polite society" is a recipe for a society where nobody speaks their mind for fear of losing their life...

Re:Protesters Smash Google Shuttle Bus Piñata In Fight Again... by mc-lovin on Tuesday May 07, 2013 @05:49PM (#5671063)
Free speech is the point because if the government decided that expressing a political opinion counted as provocation in an assault or battery charge, this would probably violate the first amendment. Legally the issue is around assault and battery, but the underlying issue is freedom of speech.

"The first amendment doesn't protect you from blowback and it's not supposed to."

Correct that is what the criminal code, and the fascist police, are for.

"Freedom of speech is not freedom from criticism."

This discussion is about violence, not criticism.

"However if you consider freedom of speech an issue between citizens, wouldn't the right to bear arms be the greatest enemy of freedom of speech? Seems like "an armed society is a polite society" is a recipe for a society where nobody speaks their mind for fear of losing their life..."

Possibly though I haven't heard of someone getting shot for expressing an opinion. Most people are afraid to go to jail for murder, while leftists who push and shove rarely even get charged.