I (John Kozubik / rsync.net) will donate USD 10,000 to wikipedia if they change their official stance to inclusionism, and adopt a "all well formed articles belong" stance.
Yes, most of what is in deletionpedia is garbage. Yes, it deserved to be deleted. But somewhere in there are thousands of articles that people spent hours on, in good faith, zapped away due to "notability". If it's well formed, it gets in.
It's gone, redirects to "cold chills" [1] which is not only incorrect, it's a far inferior article to begin with.
Having given up on contributing or editing things in WP due to the rampant and frustrating deletionism I have no idea how to even begin the labyrinthine process of getting the old article returned. The only thing I can find of it is a history where sometime in 2007 it was marked for redirection...but I know that it worked at least through 2010 and into 2011 (my own comment history has a link to it back then).
Your frustration is shared by many, many people. Here's a well formed article on a software package:
http://deletionpedia.dbatley.com/w/index.php?title=EleBBS_(d...
that was deleted because some kids hadn't heard of RA before. There are thousands of these.
if that is the case, that's infuriating, I wonder how many tens of thousands of man hours and how much knowledge has been vaporized in this way
poof
The donations go to Wikimedia, the organization that runs the servers. It is purposedly distinct from the various communities of the various language editions of the various Wikimedia projects. I do not think it would be a good thing for the Wikimedia Foundation to start imposing views on the community like you would have them do.
If you have some better idea how these things should be handled, then please explain.