News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Peter Thiel - You are Not a Lottery Ticket [video] by kami8845 on Monday May 06, 2013 @09:05AM (#5662082)
Why learn from the guy who made the mistakes when you can learn from the guy who didn't?
Re:Peter Thiel - You are Not a Lottery Ticket [video] by Millennium on Monday May 06, 2013 @09:15AM (#5662135)
Because success generally changes things, while mistakes generally don't. You can't clone a previous success exactly, because its presence alters the environment from the one in which it was initially achieved, and you have to account for that. You essentially have to show the same sort of creativity as the original success showed, and thus you haven't really learned much.

By contrast, things that were mistakes in the past tend to still be mistakes in the present. Usually they continue to be mistakes in the future as well. That's something you can really learn from, as you go through the creative process toward success that you were going to have to go through anyway.

Re:Peter Thiel - You are Not a Lottery Ticket [video] by throwaway1979 on Monday May 06, 2013 @11:42AM (#5662932)
A key word is "tend". I've tried to learn from past failures only to realize that the world has changed in a few short span and my lesson no longer applied. In the immortals words of a song "what was once good, now is bad". When one realizes this, life gets a bit harder.
Re:Peter Thiel - You are Not a Lottery Ticket [video] by jiggy2011 on Monday May 06, 2013 @09:30AM (#5662217)
I guess you should try and learn from both, but in general we pay more attention to the successes than the failures.

As an extreme example, a lottery winner should say "you should play the lottery, it made me rich!" ignoring all of those who made an overall loss.

Think of it like the housing crash, everybody knew somebody who was getting rich from property.

Re:Peter Thiel - You are Not a Lottery Ticket [video] by darkxanthos on Monday May 06, 2013 @09:37AM (#5662259)
The best thing you can hope to learn from someone you view as having made no mistakes is that they've made just as many if not more than others.

Also because survivorship bias: http://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Survivorship_bias

EDIT: Linked to Wikipedia

Re:Peter Thiel - You are Not a Lottery Ticket [video] by jdotjdot on Monday May 06, 2013 @09:37AM (#5662263)
I'm not sure why you assume he didn't make any mistakes, or even that he didn't make any serious one. Just because he was ultimately successful doesn't mean there was a lot more behind it than pure "right-decision-making" or skill.

How many great people never finished their works because of something completely outside of their control?

Re:Peter Thiel - You are Not a Lottery Ticket [video] by michaelochurch on Monday May 06, 2013 @10:28AM (#5662572)
It's not either/or. You generally need to learn from both.

The problem is social stratification. If you're a normal person, you end up mostly around people who didn't succeed and get only half the story. If you have a break-out success (or just luck) you end up in a world where everyone has, and there's a lot of self-congratulatory just-worlding. Either way, you get a biased account.

I think it's most adaptive to learn from both sides while playing the attitude of the successful, to make yourself seem like a high-status person. You always want to seem (except to true friends whom you'd actually like to help, with accurate information) like you've had an unbroken chain of successes and can't imagine anything else; you just don't want that to bleed into self-deception. Maybe the reason why psychopaths do so well in life is that they're most resistant against cognitive dissonance. It's easy for them to maintain a successful front without falling into self-deception or delusion. For everyone else, there's nonzero cognitive load in doing that.

Re:Peter Thiel - You are Not a Lottery Ticket [video] by Spooky23 on Monday May 06, 2013 @01:06PM (#5663396)
So in your universe, you're a superstar, psychopath, or failure?

The meaning of "success" is subjective. Don't self-deceive yourself into adopting somebody else's definition of "success". Peter Theil has a vested interest in you adopting success criteria that will ultimately enrich him. (That isn't a criticism)

I had a friend who was a priest. He owned almost nothing, and probably had less than $5,000 to his name. His vision of success was helping people who were indigent, incorrigible or otherwise considered broken by society. Was he a failure?

Re:Peter Thiel - You are Not a Lottery Ticket [video] by vixus on Monday May 06, 2013 @10:37AM (#5662617)
> psychopaths do so well in life

Do they?

Re:Peter Thiel - You are Not a Lottery Ticket [video] by michaelochurch on Monday May 06, 2013 @10:53AM (#5662705)
On their own terms, yes.

The serial killers are the lower classes of psychopaths, usually with other mental issues.

They don't all become CEOs but they generally rise to the highest level permissible by their intelligence. An 80-IQ psychopath isn't going to rise to the top of a bank, but he will end up in a position of power over other people.

Of course, they blow themselves up every few years or so, but they usually move away unharmed.

Re:Peter Thiel - You are Not a Lottery Ticket [video] by mindcrime on Monday May 06, 2013 @11:32AM (#5662897)
I don't know if there's been a lot of rigorous academic research on the topic or not, but there have been a handful of articles in the pop business press, talking about the connection between being "CEO material" and displaying the traits of a psychopath. For example:

http://www.forbes.com/sites/jeffbercovici/2011/06/14/why-som...

Re:Peter Thiel - You are Not a Lottery Ticket [video] by michaelochurch on Monday May 06, 2013 @12:20PM (#5663131)
Psychopaths are genetically built to be extreme r-strategists (see: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/R-strategist ). What seem like stupid social behaviors are actually practice so that, when they are in a high-stakes social situation, they can win it. Most people find the psychopaths around them to be petty and stupid and think, "How could that guy ever succeed?" Well, the psychopath has decided that you're not of primary importance to the game he is trying to play, so he's using you for practice.

By the time they're adults, psychopaths have a wealth of social experience and knowledge, often gained from high-pressure social situations they created at a rate exceeding what most people would ever encounter. When they want something, they're very good at playing to win.

The prehistoric context was that developing an outsized social ability enabled someone to have an above-normal number of sexual encounters. The lack of emotional attachment and compassion, likewise, keeps them from pair-bonding and slows down their proliferation.

In the work context, organizations are also r- or K-selective (quantity vs. quality) in how they replicate process. Get-big-or-die companies are r-strategists, while "lifestyle businesses" tend to be K-strategic. As the business world becomes increasingly r-strategic, so does the character of people running it.