News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Java 7 Features Backported to Android by JoshTriplett on Monday May 06, 2013 @02:10AM (#5661113)
OpenJDK does not have a field of use restriction; if it did, Linux distributions would not ship it as Open Source software (it wouldn't appear in Debian main, for instance).

The Java compatibility test suite does have some such restrictions, but those same restrictions would have prevented using it on Harmony too.

Re:Show HN: Java 7 Features Backported to Android by koko775 on Monday May 06, 2013 @02:25AM (#5661144)
It can't be called Java unless it passes the TCK. Even so, it only gets a limited trademark license unless you're a paying customer of Oracle. Well fine, without licensing then passing the TCK, you can't call it Java, so what?

Well, since you're foregoing certification, even if you're deriving substantially from the OpenJDK, you're also foregoing the automatic patent grants. And since it's GPLv2, not GPLv3, Oracle or any of the companies who collaborated in the patent licensing scheme, is now free to sue you for billions or trillions.

So no, OpenJDK has a field-of-use restriction in that the only way for a company to build a successful product (or even a failed one) based on it and not get sued into oblivion is to license and pass the TCK to get the license for trademarks and protection for patents.

Here's a link which should prove informative: http://dirkriehle.com/2011/06/30/the-java-ip-story/

Re:Show HN: Java 7 Features Backported to Android by andorekandore on Monday May 06, 2013 @05:44AM (#5661563)
“...is now free to sue you for billions or trillions”

Do you really mean trillions, or was that a typo...?

Re:Show HN: Java 7 Features Backported to Android by rst on Monday May 06, 2013 @03:02PM (#5664106)
What Oracle wanted out of the Android/Java-IP lawsuit was an up-front payment in the billions, plus an ongoing cut of Google's android revenue. If they'd won on copyright, which lasts for decades, that could have accrued into a colossal sum of money over time...