News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Enstitute, an Alternative to College for a Digital Elite by derefr on Sunday May 05, 2013 @09:58PM (#5660574)
Technically, this is what high school is supposed to do. That's why the government is willing to pay for it.

If it's not doing that, we probably need more of it. Maybe move all the "general liberal-arts undergrad education" into just being grades 13-16?

Re:Enstitute, an Alternative to College for a Digital Elite by nitrogen on Monday May 06, 2013 @04:38AM (#5661414)
If it's not doing that, we probably need more of it.

One must be careful with this type of reasoning. It leads to all kinds of madness. I'll leave coming up with examples as an exercise for the reader; there are too many to list.

Edit: I will give one example: a homeowner is disappointed that the lawn he or she fertilizes once a month is turning brown and growing poorly. Fertilizer is supposed to make plants grow, right? So if the plants aren't growing, add more? Now, after being fertilized once per week, the lawn dies.

Re:Enstitute, an Alternative to College for a Digital Elite by derefr on Monday May 06, 2013 @12:09PM (#5663078)
This is one of those cases where I started with a disclaimer, and then removed it to make my statement more pithy, because of course it doesn't apply in general--so the Principle of Charity should tell you I'm working from the facts of the specific case, instead of making an inference from a (misguided) universal. :)

Specifically, my original statement was going to be:

> If high school isn't accomplishing its goals (of giving citizens the tools to participate in democracy) -- and we see the need to supplement that education with years of additional university education to achieve the originally-intended effect -- then we probably just need to make those years of university education part of high school, mandatory, and free.

Re:Enstitute, an Alternative to College for a Digital Elite by voidlogic on Monday May 06, 2013 @04:57PM (#5664728)
I don't think the "general liberal-arts undergrad education" is as effective if students still live at home. Living in very new environment helps students be more open to new ideas. I think this especially true where the students home environment is anti-science or bigoted.