See the article Why Can’t Walmart Be More Like Costco?[0] for more on this.
0: http://www.thedailybeast.com/articles/2012/11/26/why-can-t-w...
The rest of her argument appears to be "I don't know if that would work for Walmart". Neither do I, but "I don't know" isn't a persuasive argument. :)
Walmart sells 140k skus, sorted on shelves and available in small quantities, and has lots of cashiers so you can get in and out reasonably quickly. Costco sells 4k skus, mostly in bulk, and forces you to wait 20 minutes to leave the store.
The irony is, I was particularly poorly served by the advice I offered here, since skipping straight to Yglesias totally screwed me up.
Sorry about that.
http://stfudamnit.com/2013/05/04/poverty-toilet-paper-and-th...
It means things are directly comparable across brands and sizes ("how does this 117g portion compare to this 270g one?"). It's a fantastic bit of legislation.
http://www.extension.org/pages/45117/is-unit-pricing-mandato...
I had no idea that the question Why can't Walmart treat its workers better, since Costco has proved it possible was not only a thing, but mature enough in the lifecycle of thingness for Mcardle to write an entire piece about how much it annoys her. I just arrived at it from observation in the stores. Well, that plus an article or two about Costco.
Strange that Walmart customer support was 100x better.
They're doing something right I think.
The membership is the per member profit. Costco doesn't mark up items more than 14%. In some states they aren't allowed to require membership to access the pharmacy. If what you proposed was workable, I'd expect groups of people in an area to band together or have a middleman in order to only have one membership and break up bulk items.
(And technically there is such a middleman doing their best to lower prices - they are called Walmart.)
> ... greater purchasing power get access to the lowest cost ...
Same thing happens with the US health system - the uninsured pay the most for exactly the same procedures at the same place. At least in the case of Costco it is economically sensible because buyers purchase a bigger volume and the store has greater throughput. (Costco typically has 4,000 SKUs per store while a normal supermarket will be around 16,000.)
Honest question, I've never heard of such a construction.
Edit: there's one big difference, though. To shop at Costco you have to buy twice as much (plus typically pay membership fees). That step could be too steep for the people most living hand-to-mouth, even though it would save them money within weeks. So there could be sample bias here too.