News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by chadmalik on Thursday April 16, 2009 @02:14PM (#565564)
And just imagine the infrastructure we could have had for the cost of the Iraq war + the bank bailouts!

Anyway one thing I'd like to mention that never gets highlighted is that buses are BY FAR the cheapest public transportation solution. Its not sexy but the good old fashioned bus is great since it can use the road infrastructure already built whereas trains need right of way and a lot of construction before they can be used.

Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by jcdreads on Thursday April 16, 2009 @02:22PM (#565580)
You're right that new bus routes have a very low marginal cost, and that buses move more people per transportation dollar than other forms of public transportation, but without expensive dedicated lanes they are certain to be slower than cars, and therefore most otherwise merry takers of public transportation avoid using them.

Another unfortunate problem with buses is that changing the bus route is pretty much trivially easy, with the consequence that they do change an awful lot (at least here in Boston), which means that buses generally provide really unreliable transportation.

Montreal has a great bus system, iirc. Dedicated roads, dedicated, clean, underground tunnels. Probably super expensive. Alas.

Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by Herring on Thursday April 16, 2009 @05:23PM (#565924)
"And just imagine the infrastructure we could have had for the cost of the Iraq war + the bank bailouts"

It's impossible to sell such a huge plan without an imminent threat/disaster. It makes no sense to think of other things we could do with that money.

Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by Retric on Thursday April 16, 2009 @08:28PM (#566164)
You can always make something up.

See: Sending a man to the moon.

Granted it might be hard to sell a rail project like the space race, but looking back on just how much of our GDP we where spending to play golf on the moon was insane.

Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by Herring on Thursday April 16, 2009 @11:50PM (#566357)
I'd argue the USSR was the imminent threat. According to wiki, Khrushchev openly & repeatedly threatened the West with nuclear annihilation. The space race was a bid to regain technological supremacy after sputnik.

Also back then it wasn't clear that it would be just the one trip.

Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by wlievens on Friday April 17, 2009 @08:52AM (#566805)
Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by Herring on Saturday April 18, 2009 @12:45PM (#568478)
yeah. Nothing new happened so i just lump them as one.
Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by omouse on Thursday April 16, 2009 @02:29PM (#565602)
If you're going to talk about buses you have to distinguish between intercity travel and innercity travel.
Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by briansmith on Thursday April 16, 2009 @02:38PM (#565612)
I used to travel by bus instead of train all the time when I was in Thailand because the bus was always faster and cheaper than the trains. The only way trains are better is if they are much faster than buses.
Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by omouse on Thursday April 16, 2009 @02:43PM (#565622)
Which is what we're talking about here. High speed trains. It's like half the people commenting here haven't read the article or something.
Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by briansmith on Thursday April 16, 2009 @03:01PM (#565654)
Did you read the part of the article where it mentioned the groups that want us to spend money on barely-faster-than-driving trains?
Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by FlorinAndrei on Thursday April 16, 2009 @03:33PM (#565730)
In places like the SF Bay Area, that's kind of a moot point.
Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by radu_floricica on Thursday April 16, 2009 @05:21PM (#565922)
High speed train is more of an alternative to flying then to buses. Taking into consideration time spent to get to/from the airport, security checks and occasional delays, trains are better under 1000 km, and may be worth it for a lot more.
Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by udfalkso on Thursday April 16, 2009 @05:53PM (#565970)
After one terrorist attack on a train, all of the security restrictions will become just as cumbersome as air travel's.
Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by JesseAldridge on Thursday April 16, 2009 @06:36PM (#566036)
Important difference: you can't fly a train into a building.

Edit: easily :)

Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by alecco on Thursday April 16, 2009 @09:07PM (#566196)
Eurostar checks are very tight and even on busy days it won't take over an hour of queuing at Gare du Nord. Usually there aren't so many trains to board so it's much easier to organize. I suffered a whole station lock-down on a busy Sunday night due to a large piece of luggage left near the security checkpoint. It delayed my trip only 2 hours, including the delays of not being on time for the cleared route. Another thing is trains don't usually have busy schedule of airplanes so they usually wait for people if something like that happens.

Also there's no fuel around to use as explosive material.

Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by radu_floricica on Thursday April 16, 2009 @06:33PM (#566030)
Spain had its share of train terrorist attacks, and at least in the rest of the Europe you can't tell. I don't know about inside Spain, though, but I imagine it's still not much difference.
Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by udfalkso on Thursday April 16, 2009 @06:35PM (#566032)
True. But we tend to overreact here in the US.
Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by papaf on Friday April 17, 2009 @10:34AM (#566990)
In Spain they X-ray your luggage before you can get to the platform for most long distance trains.
Re:Obama Unveils Plan to Fund High-Speed Passenger Rail by rjurney on Thursday April 16, 2009 @05:42PM (#565952)
To make buses work in a modern city, you need dedicated bus lanes. Mexico City has em, and they are amazing. Without bus lanes, buses suck for inner-city travel. They are slow, and traffic sucks.

But this is about connecting cities in densely populated regions, not transportation within cities: http://www.fra.dot.gov/downloads/Research/hsr_corridors_2009...

Buses between cities is a terrible way to travel. I know, I took buses from east/west coast repeatedly as a teenager.